>> ASIAONE / NEWS / ASIAONE NEWS / ASIAN OPINIONS / STORY
Tainted products
Tue, Sep 30, 2008
Philippine Daily Inquirer

By Editorial Desk

From the 1930s to the 1950s, the label 'Made in Japan' was practically a brand for cheap but low-quality goods. Since then, Japan's industries have made great advances in technology and quality control, and now Japanese goods are at par with, if not even better than, American and European merchandise. Now, it is the 'Made in China' label that is perceived as a brand for cheap but shoddy goods.

Over the years there have been complaints about goods made in China, but it is only now that a worldwide furor has occurred over a particular kind of merchandise. The uproar over melamine-laced milk manufactured in China has pointed up the fact that goods made with certain chemicals to make them appear better or to give them a longer shelf life can truly and literally kill. Tainted milk has killed four babies and made 53,000 others ill in China.

Complaints about tainted Chinese products started to gain intensity last year. In April 2007 the US Food and Drug Administration discovered through tests that cats and dogs had been poisoned by Chinese pet food ingredients tainted with melamine. Melamine is a toxic industrial chemical that can cause kidney stones and lead to kidney failure.

The FDA began warning consumers about lead paint in toys, defective tires and toothpaste containing diethylene glycol, a toxic ingredient found in antifreeze. In June 2007 China closed down 180 food factories after inspectors found that industrial chemicals such as formaldehyde were being used to make candies, pickles, crackers and seafood. Formaldehyde is a disinfectant and preservative that is believed to cause cancer in human beings.

In the Philippines, one high-profile case suspected to have involved a Chinese-made product was the death in a fire of the daughter of then-Speaker Jose de Venecia. The fire was believed to have started from a Christmas tree lighted up by defective decorations made in China. In July 2007 the Bureau of Food and Drugs began examining more than 800 products from China, including cosmetics, toothpaste, candies and cookies. Recently, Health Secretary Francisco Duque ordered several dairy products and milk products with ingredients from China to be taken off grocery shelves.

The question is often asked: Can people do without goods made in China or products whose parts or ingredients were made in China? It appears that the answer to that question is "no" because China has become the factory of the world. Name almost any product that is bought and used today throughout the world - from candies to computers - and if it was not manufactured in China, then at least one ingredient or one part was made in its factories.

Journalist James Fallows has said that Americans complain about "cheap junk pouring out of Chinese mills, but they rely on China for a lot that is not junk, and whose cheap price is important to American industrial and domestic life". And cheap Chinese goods have made it possible for the people of developing countries to buy goods that otherwise they would not be able to afford if these were imported at higher prices from the developed world.

China has become the factory of the world because of its low wage level which has made it possible for its products to be competitive with the products of other countries. In Guangdong, for instance, the minimum wage is US$5.86 a day, a little higher than the $5.54 a day in Bangkok. In Manila, the non-agricultural minimum wage is about $8.17 a day, and in South Korea, $24 a day.

Labor may be cheap in China, but it is its being cheap and efficient that has fueled the fast growth of its economy. In the process, shortcuts have been taken, some ingredients have been used to make some products look better and have a longer shelf life, and some substandard parts have been used in making some goods.

It is to China's credit, however, that it is acting fast to salvage the reputation of its products. Last week, it embarked on a sweeping drive to set up a series of new food testing centers and replace outdated equipment. Prime Minister Wen Jiabao promised to ensure that the 'Made in China' brand is safe for consumers at home and abroad. "We will make the entire 'Made in China' brand worry-free and reputable for both the Chinese and the people across the world," Wen said. The world, which has become dependent on cheap, affordable products made in China, can only hope that the situation will be remedied, that China will follow the route taken by Japan, and that henceforth, quality and safety will not be sacrificed for price and profit.

 

READERS' POSTINGS
"This is great to keep overseas Singaporeans connected to home news and affairs"

"My favourite was "The Aftermath for Malaysia Election" - (in my opinion), this was a very well crafted world standard image, it is even suitable for a Time magazine cover!"
Read more

 

 
STORY INDEX
 
  Are investment banks too risky?
   
 
  Roller-coaster image of China also of its own doing
   
 
  US financial crisis to affect Thailand in medium, long term
   
 
  Can the PM's son-in-law win?
   
 
  Presidential hopefuls cannot ignore Asia
   
 
  Tainted products
   
 
  Reality check from stunt gone wrong
   
 
  We are what we read
   
 
  A drop of milk
   
 
  On the suicide of a friend: A listening ear could have helped
   
>> RELATED STORY
Roller-coaster image of China also of its own doing
S'pore, China break ground on eco-city
5 more food items contaminated
More measures needed to protect food consumers
Nearly 53,000 Chinese children sickened by milk powder

Elsewhere in AsiaOne...

Investor Relations: Four Singapore firms invest $127m in Tianjin

Wine,Dine&Unwind: Finding oneself in the shadow of a monk

Travel: Travel to Taiwan eased

Health: Shoppers switch to non-China milk

Motoring: China biggest carbon polluter, say scientists

Digital: China shut 44,000 porn websites in 2007

Business: Tainted products

Multimedia: 16 killed in China ahead of Games

 

We welcome contributions, comments and tips.
a1admin@sph.com.sg
   

Search: