>> ASIAONE / NEWS / EDUCATION / STORY
Chinese netizens oppose language character changes
Tue, Oct 20, 2009
AFP

Beijing - More than 50 years after a major overhaul of the way in which Chinese characters are written, a far less ambitious project to simplify just a few dozen ideograms has sparked huge controversy here.

The government has put forward proposals to change 44 characters out of the 3,500 most used - or 1.25 per cent of the total - 'to adapt to the requirements of the information era, the evolution of language and the development of society'.

After eight years of reflection and expert consultations in China and abroad, the education ministry and the State Language Work Committee called on members of the public for their opinions - a first for such a reform.

The project was not expected to spark major concerns, with just a few strokes removed from characters here and there.

For example, cha, or tea, would lose a tiny upward stroke at its base - a change that is already noticeable on some shopfronts in Beijing.

Xin, which means new, would also get rid of its little upward line.

But dissenting voices have run riot, particularly on the Internet.

According to polls by major Chinese web portals or newspaper websites, more than 80 per cent of online users are opposed to the project.

They say the reform might affect only a few characters, but these are used often and their modification would have an important impact on dictionaries, books, signs, publishers and the Chinese themselves.

'Chinese characters are a precious part of the cultural heritage left to us by our ancestors thousands of years ago,' one Internet user in eastern Shandong said in a comment posted on sina.com

'We should respect them and protect them, not change them on a whim.'

Mr Liu Jingbo, a calligraphy professional who regularly organises exhibitions in Beijing, said the changes would not go against the nation's history.

'Chinese characters come from ancient history but it is possible to reform them, respecting certain rules, if it helps to make life easier.

'A lot of people such as the elderly are, however, opposed to this as they are used to these characters.'

In the 1950s, when the government decided to simplify more than 2,000 characters, the philologist Chen Mengjia paid dearly for his opposition to this huge reform project.

Accused of being a 'rightist' and sent to a labour camp, he subsequently committed suicide in 1966 after being subjected to public criticism sessions at the start of the turbulent Cultural Revolution.

Experts say the new controversy highlights the strong public attachment to the Chinese form of writing - a unifying factor within the massive country of 1.3billion people, which boasts many languages and dialects.

'Of the first measures taken by the first emperor after he defeated all other kingdoms, the unification of writing was not insignificant,' said Beijing-based researcher Olivier Venture for the French School of Asian Studies.

'It is extremely important. It is seen as the bond that unites Chinese culture, as part of the nation's identity.

'A lot of things change but people can always look to writing, even if it always evolves.'

Faced with the surge of protests on the Internet and in the press during the consultation phase in August, the education ministry and the commission decided to wait, saying nothing had been decided and that discussions were ongoing.

'We are civil servants. Our responsibility is to serve the people,' said official Li Ningming at the commission in comments broadcast on state television.

 

 

 
 
STORY INDEX
 
  Chinese netizens oppose language character changes
   
 
  France suspends college boss in fake degree probe
   
 
  Higher cost puts off Malaysian students studying in Indonesia
   
 
  Shoddy maintenance compromises school safety
   
 
  Can't decimate these 'deformed' words
   
 
  Parents up in arms over PSLE maths paper, but...
   
 
  A taste of the Norwegian way
   
 
  Senior educators appointed Sinda and Mendaki chiefs
   
 
  Wii, it's time for PE
   
 
  Students in uniform 'grope and kiss every morning' on bus
   
We welcome contributions, comments and tips.
a1admin@sph.com.sg