>> ASIAONE / NEWS / LATEST NEWS / ASIA / STORY
China's Africa investments under harsh spotlight
Fri, Nov 06, 2009
AFP

By Joelle Garrus

As Chinese firms pour billions of dollars into mining, energy and infrastructure deals in Africa, Beijing is turning a blind eye to rogue regimes that stand to reap the benefits, observers say.

Guinea's military rulers are the latest on the continent to receive a pledge of a massive infusion of Chinese cash -- at least seven billion dollars over five years in the mining sector from China Investment Fund (CIF).

With Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao heading to Egypt for a summit with African leaders this weekend, observers say his government should be held more accountable for opaque investments made by firms with possible state links. Related article: China Premier heads to Africa

Kissy Agyeman-Togobo, at IHS Global Insight, said the deal "could provide Guinea's junta with financial independence from traditional Western donors in the wake of security force brutalities... in which over 150 people died".

It "once again throws up the question of China's oft-criticised approach of dealing with dubious regimes, particularly at this sensitive time when Guinea's relationship with the international community hangs in the balance".

In September, troops opened fire at a public rally in Conakry held in protest against junta leader captain Moussa Dadis Camara ahead of presidential elections planned for January. The regime says 56 people were killed.

From oil in Sudan, Angola and Nigeria to bauxite in Guinea, China has been pouring money into natural resources not only in Africa but also around the globe, with other investments in Peruvian iron and Mongolian copper.

Over the past five years, Chinese direct investment in Africa has soared, from 491 million dollars in 2003 to 7.8 billion dollars in 2008, according to official Chinese figures. Related article: China's thirst for African oil

The investment spree is designed to gain access to resources to fuel China's hectic economic growth. Beijing says investments like the CIF one -- announced less than two weeks after the bloodshed in Conakry -- are strictly private.

But a recent report by the US-China Economic and Security Review Commission, a panel of experts chosen by Congress, suggested that Hong Kong-based CIF was in fact part of a nebulous group of companies with links to the state.

"There is evidence that several of its key personnel have ties to Chinese state-owned enterprises and government agencies... and possibly China's intelligence apparatus," the commission said.

But Syetarn Hansakul, a Singapore-based analyst for Deutsche Bank, said she was not convinced that the ruling Communist party was pulling strings on deals made abroad by Chinese firms.

"The government explicitly said, 'We need to build up energy resources and reserves'," Hansakul told AFP.

"When they receive a broad mandate like that... naturally companies think 'We need to secure (resources)'. But they choose the countries where they invest.

"There is no agenda (...) to support any government or group," said Hansakul. "It is commercially-driven, it is business-dealing, sometimes with consequences."

Barry Sautman, an associate professor of social science at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, said China did not deserve to be singled out for investments made with controversial regimes.

In Sudan, "China is certainly not alone in developing the oil industry", Sautman said, noting that it was linked to projects in which India's ONGC and Malaysia's Petronas, both state-owned firms, held major stakes.

Both firms, in addition to China's PetroChina and Sinopec, have been accused by US non-profit organisation Investors Against Genocide of "helping to fund the genocide in Darfur" in western Sudan.

 
 
STORY INDEX
 
  China's Africa investments under harsh spotlight
   
 
  Indian Sikhs defy advice to pray in Pakistan
   
 
  Vietnam storm and flood toll rises to 107
   
 
  Hungry 'roos plague outback town
   
 
  Wang Chuanfu tops Forbes China rich list
   
 
  China's richest see their wealth double
   
 
  China air force to mark 60th with aerial display
   
 
  Appointing Thaksin 'an insult' to Thai justice system
   
 
  China air force to mark 60th with aerial display
   
 
  Thai-Cambodian relations face-off
   
>> RELATED STORY
China air force to mark 60th with aerial display
China air force to mark 60th with aerial display
China bans physical punishment for Internet addicts
50% of new expats leave China early
Mother marches 2,000km to save son

Elsewhere in AsiaOne...

Investor Relations: Mid-East backers sign on dotted line to launch mega Johor project

Wine,Dine&Unwind: Finding oneself in the shadow of a monk

Travel: Free for foreigners, not Chinese

Health: China's Sinovac gets additional H1N1 vaccine order

Motoring: Long road ahead for China's green cars

Digital: Oodles of woe for Google

Business: Starbucks raises outlook as turnaround signs mount

Multimedia: 16 killed in China ahead of Games

 

We welcome contributions, comments and tips.
a1admin@sph.com.sg