Top investors, strategists take pummeling in Wall St sell-off

Top investors, strategists take pummeling in Wall St sell-off

BOSTON - Some of Wall Street's biggest names are licking their wounds as October lives up to its reputation as one of the market's roughest months.

The Standard & Poor's 500 index has now lost almost 8 per cent in the past three-and-a-half weeks , wiping out almost all of the gains achieved earlier in 2014. What seemed like another good year for investors in US equities is now fraught with uncertainty, with $1.3 trillion in S&P companies' market value disappearing. Add in the impact of an oil price slump plus a big surprise rally in US Treasuries, and the risks of big investment losses have risen dramatically.

From top equity strategists to big hedge funds and mutual funds, the carnage has spared few. Morgan Stanley strategists said this week that their model portfolio through Monday had trailed the S&P by 3.6 percentage points due to bad bets on technology stocks, including GT Advanced Technologies, the Apple supplier that surprised investors with a bankruptcy filing last week.

Billionaire investor Carl Icahn, had indicated for some time that he was prepared for a stock market reversal but it is unclear whether he would have been fully hedged against a 27 per cent drop in the shares of online video company Netflix on Wednesday after it reported slower US growth. Icahn's Icahn Enterprises owned 1.8 million shares at the end of the second quarter. He could not be immediately reached for comment.

The average US equity mutual fund through Tuesday was down 2.3 per cent on the year, according to Morningstar data, trailing the S&P, which is up a meager 0.8 per cent. Meanwhile, leveraged ETFs, which try to double the performance of key averages, are doing worse - a popular leveraged bond ETF that bets on higher long-dated yields has lost 16 per cent in the last 20 days. The Proshares Ultra S&P 500 fund - an ETF that looks to double the S&P's performance - is down 14 per cent in 19 days.

Top equity strategists at major investment banks polled this year by Reuters have also been caught wrong-footed. They steadily boosted their bets on the rally continuing. The median S&P 500 year-end forecast has been steadily climbing, from a median of 1,925 in December 2013, to 2,000 in June, and then 2,033 in a Sept. 25 poll.


Still, some investors fear there is a lot worse to come - and this time they are concerned that the US Federal Reserve won't be in a position to stem the selloff as it has done in recent years. The Fed is likely to be reluctant to engage in more quantitative easing, the pumping of money into the financial system through bond purchases.

"I fear tomorrow could be worse," said James Sanford, portfolio manager at SAG Harbor Advisors, adding that "while we haven't seen the swings we saw in 2011, some of the problems we had at that time are still with us and this time the cavalry in the form of the Fed isn't coming to save us."

To be sure, after a five-year bull market on Wall Street, many big-name investors cautioned that a pullback was long overdue. But the suddenness of the move has been an awakening for fund managers and strategists, many of whom had doubled down on their bullishness as the year wore on, steadily increasing bets on more gains in equities.

One of those was Dan Greenhaus, strategist at brokerage BTIG LLC, who lamented in a note on Tuesday evening that he was one of the Street's last strategists to raise his S&P year-end target - to 2,100 on September 18, just before the market took a turn for the worse.

Greenhaus had expected weakness in equities at some point, but by September bought into the thesis that underperforming hedge funds would buy into the advance, leading to a "catch-up" trade. Greenhaus did not return calls seeking comment.

However, many hedge funds have run for cover at the first sign of trouble, adding to the sell-off's speed and intensity.

They've responded by exiting largely popular trades, particularly in energy stocks, that had become losers. Hedge fund favourite Cheniere Energy Inc tumbled 14.5 per cent in five days, and Anadarko Petroleum Corp, another stock widely held by hedge funds, dropped 12.8 per cent. Drugs company Gilead Sciences Inc, also popular with hedge funds, has lost 12.6 per cent in five days.

And then there are losses associated with failed deals including news that AbbVie is reconsidering its bid for biotech company Shire, possibly dealing a fresh blow to hedge fund titan John Paulson, who had a big bet on Shire and publicly praised the deal only a few weeks ago.

Shire's value plunged more than 20 per cent on Wednesday from around $49 billion to $39 billion, potentially wiping around $500 million from the value of Paulson's stake and $270 million off Elliott Management's stake, according to Reuters calculations.

Credit Suisse Prime Services data show that hedge funds' most popular long positions fell 8.6 per cent during the first nine days of October, compared with a 5 per cent drop for the S&P 500.

The bankruptcy of GT Advanced, which had a contract to supply Apple with sapphire glass, had a negative knock-on impact for many stocks, hedge fund managers say. Among its shareholders at the end of the second quarter were mutual fund giant Fidelity and many hedge funds including Whitebox, Highbridge Capital Management and Citadel.

"Hedge funds are getting crushed right now," said Peter Rup, CEO and chief investment officer at Artemis Wealth Advisors, which advises high net-worth families and foundations. "They are notoriously bad at market turns and it is going to be a horrible month. They got a little lazy and didn't take preventative measures in time."

Morgan Stanley chief equity strategist Adam Parker had also included GT in his list of favoured stocks. His portfolio included a 1 per cent allocation to GT. "Please forgive us," Parker wrote Tuesday of his bet on the stock, which has lost 93 per cent of its value this year.

Parker noted that his basket of stocks has trailed the S&P 500 through Oct. 13 by 3.6 percentage points due to weak stock selection in technology and financials and an overweighting in the consumer discretionary area. Recently added positions in stocks like software company VMware and casino company Las Vegas Sands have disappointed.

Parker was not available for comment. His note points out that the portfolio has outperformed the S&P by 6.7 percentage points since the beginning of 2011.

Purchase this article for republication.



Your daily good stuff - AsiaOne stories delivered straight to your inbox
By signing up, you agree to our Privacy policy and Terms and Conditions.