Cracks in this Shell but it holds

Cracks in this Shell but it holds
Scarlett Johansson's casting as Major Kusanagi in Ghost In The Shell has proved controversial.

You could be forgiven for thinking this year was a contest between films which can cause the most outrage.

In that regard, Ghost In The Shell (or GITS) is doing pretty well. But as an actual movie?

The fact that I went for a second round of this should tell you that it is not as terrible as some would have you think.

The cracks in this Shell are bearable.

It had been so long since the media preview screening - with so much said about it since - that GITS deserved a second opinion.

IMAX 3D emphasised two things. First, this adaptation - flawed as it is - comes from the best of intentions.

The level of creativity put in to the effects makes me believe the makers really wanted this to work. The cast works too.

Asbaek is Batou made flesh, Ng Chin Han manages to overcome the worst hairstyle in the world and Kitano proves that less is much, much more. He takes stoic presence to a supernatural level.

That said, more work is needed on the screenplay - it is littered with sloppy plot holes.

The other moment of clarity was that creating a Hollywood live-action GITS was a fool's mission from the start.

To make this a success required sacrifices - alienate the die-hard fans, or alienate general audiences.

Of course, the whitewashing issue could have been handled far better. But then, even Scarlett Johansson getting the blessing of the original 1995 anime's director Mamoru Oshii has not been enough to stop cries of foul.

For all the flash, it is only when GITS gets low-key and gritty and less beholden to copying frames from the anime that the film comes to life.

You can read the initial review and my thoughts on Chin Han's hair at


MOVIE: Ghost In The Shell

STARRING: Scarlett Johansson, Pilou Asbaek, Takeshi Kitano, Ng Chin Han, Michael Pitt

DIRECTOR: Rupert Sanders

THE SKINNY: In the future, Major (Johansson) is the first of her kind - the survivor of a terrorist attack who is turned into a cyber-enhanced soldier. But has she been lied to about her past?


This article was first published on Apr 05, 2017.
Get The New Paper for more stories.

More about

movie review
Purchase this article for republication.



Your daily good stuff - AsiaOne stories delivered straight to your inbox
By signing up, you agree to our Privacy policy and Terms and Conditions.