Here's how house brand products in Singapore compare: FairPrice vs Meadows vs RedMart vs Sheng Siong

Here's how house brand products in Singapore compare: FairPrice vs Meadows vs RedMart vs Sheng Siong
Net profit for Sheng Siong was up nearly 19 per cent to $14.5 million in the three months.
PHOTO: The Straits Times

Aside from its impact on people’s health, the Covid-19 pandemic has hit businesses and the economy hard.

Many companies in the tourism, aviation, and the oil and gas services industries have seen their revenues all but dry up.

But, supermarkets in Singapore are thriving.

Amid the recession and bad labour market, consumers are becoming more cost-conscious and turning towards supermarket house brand products.

Speaking to The Straits Times, a Dairy Farm spokesman stated that the sales for its grocery retail business have seen a double-digit increase during the Covid-19 pandemic, citing that:

“Demand for our Meadows range of products has grown proportionately with this increase,” the spokesman said, adding that the brand’s nuts and potato chip range are top sellers.

But here’s the million-dollar question. Which HouseBrand is the most affordable and how much can you expect to save switching to house brands?

To figure this out, I will be comparing the prices of house brands from FairPrice, Meadows (Dairy Farm), Sheng Siong and RedMart house brand products.

These are some of the biggest supermarket chains in Singapore with an established house brand line.

I will also be comparing the house brand prices with the cheapest name brand product that I can find, for a point of reference.

The list will consist of select items from the basket of goods used to calculate Singapore’s Consumer Price Index (CPI) for August 2020.

Information accurate as of Oct 16, 2020.

TL;DR: FairPrice vs Meadows vs RedMart vs Sheng Siong house brands

  Name Brand Meadows FairPrice RedMart Private Label Sheng Siong House Brands
Item Item & Price Item & Price Price Difference vs Name Brand Item & Price Price Difference vs Name Brand Item & Price Price Difference vs Name Brand Item & Price Price Difference vs Name Brand
Premium Thai White Rice (Per 5 Kilogram) Double Flying King AAA Thai Hom Mali Fragrant White Rice:
$13.50
Meadows Thai Fragrant Rice 5kg:
$9.70
-28 per cent Double FP Thai Hom Mali Premium Quality Fragrant Rice:
$11.90
-12 per cent RedMart Thai Hom Mali Fragrant Rice: $13.15 -3 per cent Royal Golden Grain Premium Fragrant Rice:
$13.80
+2 per cent
Ordinary White Bread (Per 400 Gram) Sunshine Soft White Bread:
$2.30
Meadows Enriched White Bread 400g: $1.60 -30 per cent FairPrice Enriched White Bread:
$1.25
-46 per cent Redmart Sliced White Bread:
$1.90
-17 per cent Bake For You Enriched White Bread:
$1.80
-22 per cent

Why choose house brands?

For shoppers, buying name brand products makes less sense when generally, the biggest difference between name brands and the house brand version is its price.

You will find that the quality of house brand products is often close to their brand name counterparts or are at least of reasonable quality.

In some cases they are even made by the same manufacturer, just packaged differently. You can tell this is the case when you compare ingredient lists.

Regardless, house brands are good for consumers, as they help lower prices overall.

This is because the more affordable house brands put pressure on name brands to produce a better product at a cheaper price.

This is likely to result in the overall average price for that product decreasing.

Comparison methodology

For this comparison, I will be using a select list of items taken from the basket of goods used to calculate Singapore’s Consumer Price Index (August 2020).

The list includes:

  1. Premium Thai White Rice (Per 5 Kilogram)
  2. Ordinary White Bread (Per 400 Gram)
  3. Instant Noodles (Per 5 Packets)
  4. Cheese (Per 12 Slices)
  5. Hen Eggs (Per 10)
  6. Canola Oil (Per 2 Kilogram)
  7. White Sugar (Per 2 Kilogram)
  8. 3 in 1 Instant Coffee (Per 15 packs)

FairPrice (NTUC) house brand

On this list, FairPrice or otherwise known as NTUC, is the most established, as it has a range of over 2,000 house brand products split into six categories.

Also, the company has also frozen the price of some of its most popular house brand products till December 2020 to help consumers cope with the ill effects of the Covid-19 pandemic.

The company is also looking to expand its exclusive house brand products; which include the recently-launched SmartChoice label that carries adult diapers and cleaning products.

Dairy Farm house brand (Meadows)

For starters, let’s look at the Meadows range of house brand products that was recently launched by the Dairy Farm group.

Meadows is the group’s first exclusive house brand with a little over 200 products ranging from fresh produce to snacks.

You can buy Meadows products from Dairy Farm supermarkets like Cold Storage, Market Place, Giant and convenience store chain 7-Eleven.

In addition, Giant has committed to reducing the prices of hundreds of its everyday essentials by an average of 20 per cent for at least six months from Sept 24, 2020.

This includes products from name brands as well as Giant’s house brand Meadows.

RedMart house brand

Next, we have RedMart, with the company selling its house brand products under the RedMart Private Label brand.

Currently, the RedMart Private Label brand has a little over 360 products ; with the company looking to expand its house-brand range to include more cooking and baking essentials.

Sheng Siong house brand

Last but not least we have Sheng Siong, and its vast array of over 1,200 house brand offerings.

There are the Happy Family, Tasty Bites, Heritage Farm and Bake For You brands.

Meadows vs FairPrice vs RedMart vs Sheng Siong house brands vs name brand price comparison

  Name Brand Meadows FairPrice RedMart Private Label Sheng Siong House Brands
Item Item & Price Item & Price Price Difference vs Name Brand Item & Price Price Difference vs Name Brand Item & Price Price Difference vs Name Brand Item & Price Price Difference vs Name Brand
Premium Thai White Rice (Per 5 Kilogram) Double Flying King AAA Thai Hom Mali Fragrant White Rice:
$13.50
Meadows Thai Fragrant Rice 5kg:
$9.70
-28 per cent Double FP Thai Hom Mali Premium Quality Fragrant Rice:
$11.90
-12 per cent RedMart Thai Hom Mali Fragrant Rice: $13.15 -3 per cent Royal Golden Grain Premium Fragrant Rice:
$13.80
+2 per cent
Ordinary White Bread (Per 400 Gram) Sunshine Soft White Bread:
$2.30
Meadows Enriched White Bread 400g: $1.60 -30 per cent FairPrice Enriched White Bread:
$1.25
-46 per cent Redmart Sliced White Bread:
$1.90
-17 per cent Bake For You Enriched White Bread:
$1.80
-22 per cent
Instant Noodles (Per 5 Packets) Myojo Chicken Tanmen Instant Noodles:
$2
Meadows Instant Noodle Chicken Flavour:
$1.45
-28 per cent FairPrice Instant Noodles - Chicken:
$1.45
-28 per cent - Happy Family Chicken Instant Noodles:
$1.50
-25 per cent
Cheese (Per 12 Slices) Anchor Cheese Slices:
$3.90
Meadows Cheese Single Sliced 12s:
$4.00
+3 per cent FairPrice Cheese Slices:
$4.15
+6 per cent -
Hen Eggs (Per 10) Chew's Corn & Soya Eggs 10S:
$2.10
Giant Premium Fresh Eggs 10s:
$1.95
-7 per cent - - RedMart 10 Eggs: $2.10 0 per cent Heritage Farm Eggs 10S:
$2.30
+9.5 per cent
Canola Oil (Per 2 Kilogram) OKI Canola Oil 2L:
$7.60
Meadows Canola Oil 2L:
$6.50
-14 per cent FairPrice Canola Oil:
$7.20
-5 per cent RedMart Canola Oil 2L:
$7.20
-5 per cent Happy Family Canola Oil 2L:
$5.45
-28 per cent
White Sugar (Per 2 Kilogram) SIS White Sugar:
$3.50
White Sugar:
$3.75
+7 per cent FairPrice Pure Cane Sugar:
$2.95
-16 per cent RedMart Fine Grain Sugar:
$3.00
-14 per cent Happy Family Fine Sugar:
$2.55
-32 per cent
3 in 1 Instant Coffee (Per 15 packs) Super 3-In-1 Instant White Coffee:
$5.95
Meadows 3 in 1 Ipoh White Coffee:
$4.95
-17 per cent FairPrice 3 in 1 Instant White Coffee:
$6.25
+5 per cent - Heritage Farm White Coffee:
$4.95
-17 per cent

*Do note that the percentages are rounded up to the nearest integer. Prices recorded are actual retail prices and do not take into account sales for a more balanced comparison. Information accurate as of Oct 16, 2020.

Overall, you will get to save quite a bit if you opt for the Supermarket house brands over name brands for household essentials.

If you switch to Meadows house brand products, you can save on average about 20 per cent for the cheaper items.

If you switch to FairPrice house brand products, you can save on average about 21 per cent for the cheaper items.

As for Sheng Siong house brand products, you can on average save about 27 per cent for the cheaper items for the most savings.

For RedMart Private Label, you can on average save about 10 per cent for the cheaper items. But for now, their range of house brands for the essentials is a bit lacking.

However, there are some things that are 3 per cent – 7 per cent more expensive if you opt for house brands.

Personally, I think this is an easy choice for me to opt for house brands as I am not too picky and want to cut back a bit during this period of uncertainty brought about by the Covid-19 pandemic.

This article was first published in Seedly.

This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.