Was Chann Sankaran an innocent bystander "set up" by UK newspaper Daily Telegraph, as suggested by Wilson Raj Perumal?
Or did Chann, who was convicted of conspiracy to commit bribery along with two others in the UK on Tuesday, play a more sinister role in global match fixing?
A series of text messages acquired by The New Paper last year suggest the latter.
The SMSes indicate that Chann, 33, was involved in attempts at fixing two matches in the Conference League in England last November.
One of his messages to a potential "investor" read: "Even I have a team in London also the pricing for the team to loss (sic) is about 60K pound, so about Singapore dollars is about $130K. Ur betting must be about $250k SG dollars."
Chann, a known associate of convicted match fixer Wilson Raj, was not aware that the "investor" was an undercover anti-corruption officer.
Chann and his syndicate had been cultivating the "investor" for more than six months when he was detained after a UK sting operation last November.
The "investor" - an investigator from Australia-based SI Sports Intelligence (SI) - had befriended Chann on Facebook.
Their conversations became more revealing when Chann, who used to own a sports and events company, started trusting the "investor".
He boasted that his syndicate had connections to national football teams and was able to fix international friendly matches and even World Cup qualifiers for the right price. Chann, a delivery assistant who lived with his sister's family in Hougang, had previously been jailed for about two years for credit card fraud. He told the "investor" of his travel plans in a text message: "I can come around 20 or 21 June (2013) to London to meet up with U bro. So we just need to bring about 100K euro to the place where the game is taking place." Wilson Raj, who has denied involvement with Chann, said the latter visited the UK three times to introduce football players to the "investor".
Wilson Raj told TNP in an e-mail last November: "Chann was broke, so he seized this opportunity when the agent promised to pass him £60,000 to bet in the matches he could fix.