They wandered into her store hoping she could help.
One was a heartbroken ballroom-dancing instructor who had just lost her job. The other, a Singaporean businesswoman, had a workplace crush.
But in the face of these troubles, Sylvia Mitchell, a fortune-teller in Greenwich Village, New York City, saw only lucrative opportunities for herself, prosecutors said.
The 39-year-old soothsayer allegedly conned the businesswoman, Ms Lee Choong, of US$128,000 (S$160,000) and Florida-based dance instructor Debra Saalfield of US$27,000.
Mitchell is on trial for grand larceny.
Ms Choong, who, in 2007, turned to Mitchell for help with unreciprocated romance, ended up giving Mitchell US$128,000 over two years, said prosecutors.
Ms Saalfield, whose trouble Mitchell said stemmed from being too attached to money, was charged US$75 for a initial consultation and later told to hand over US$27,000 as an exercise in parting with money.
Get The New Paper for more stories.