>> ASIAONE / HEALTH / WEEKEND SPECIAL / HOW MUCH ARE YOU WORTH?
 
 
 
» Middleman to be paid $300,000 to get kidney for
CK Tang boss
» Kidney-for-sale: CK Tang chairman charged with 3 counts
» Kidney-for-sale racket : Indon duo jailed and fined
» Will CK Tang chairman be charged?
» Tangs chief named in kidneys-for-sale case
» 2 Indons admit selling kidneys in first case in S'pore
» Indon embassy hires lawyer to help duo in
kidney-for-sale case
» Singapore: Awake during $50000 China kidney transplant
» Singapore: $22,000 for his kidney = 16.5 years of his pay
» Desperation drives patients to buy organs
» Cheap 'organ transplants' scam exposed
» Illegal China organ trade ends in tragedy
» Video: US dentist jailed for organ trafficking
» Filipino kidneys cheapest in world black market, says NGO
» Andrea de Cruz all for organ trade
» London hospital caught in liver transplant scandal
 
FOR »
» Get off your high horse, moral arguments a luxury
» Time for Singapore to rethink issue
» A pragmatic look at organ sales
» When life hangs by a legal thread
 
AGAINST »
» No such thing as ethical organ market
» Health Minister: It won't be legal any time soon because...
» Only wealthy and criminals will benefit if organ sales allowed
» Why the sale of organs should not be allowed
» Organ sales unfair to defenceless poor
» Don't buy into kidneys for sale argument
» Losing a kidney
» Poor will be victims of organ trade
» Morally wrong? But it can save lives
» The case for legalising organ sales in Singapore
 
ALTERNATIVES »
» Consider cloning organs
» Donate organs for points
» De facto price control on human organs
» Kidney debate: Go with common sense instead of 'by the book'
 
» "This middleman pockets $300k whilst the kidney seller get $23K?
... Exploiting and profiteering from the misery of others."
 
»

"But why can't the person who needs the organ accept that he/she will face the inevitable? In time to come, organ will be a hot sales in singapore. Another first class world country with a team of superior doctors. It has to be Uniquely Singapore! So why not? Win-win situation."

 
»

"Allowing organ trading will only encourage 'snake heads' who would kidnap the poor (in certain rurual areas of certain countries), remove their organs agst their will and sell them. We cannot deny a person of his health if there are ways to do it without harming another person."

 
»

"If we allow casinos and prostitutes in many areas of Singapore, why should we not allow the sale of kidneys? I guess we all got 2 kidneys, may be one of them is destined for sharing, with or without money."

 
»

"The society as a whole penalise the poor easily rather then the rich...I think the syndicate and the buyers deserve much heavier penalty than those poor people."

   
»

"U earn money, another person earns his life back. What's the problem? Imagine... the day will come when illegitimate children are born and reared like cattle and pigs in some third-world country to be 'harvested' for their organs for sale once they are 'matured'."

 
» Buy an organ? YES. Sell an organ? NO.
» Kedah man donates organs
» Their blood types don't match, but he's getting her kidney
» She's living new life, thanks to donor rule
» Skinning the dead to heal the living
» Protecting the giver of the ultimate gift
» Paying tribute to Muslim couple
» A dialysis patient's plea to the Government
 
Singapore
» Patients hire 'referral agents' as medical tour guides
» Skin shortage
» 'Let independent panel okay donors'
» Multi-layered checks keep illegal cases down
» Mt Elizabeth okays another transplant as probe continues
India
» Greeks caught up in Indian organ trade scandal--ministry
» India gets tough on organ transplants
Philippines
» NBI to investigate doctors' involvement in organ trade
» 'No basis to charge organ donation board'
» CBCP calls for stronger laws vs organ sale
» DoH: Aliens on wait list exempted from kidney transplant ban
» Cautious welcome for Philippine transplant ban
Malaysia
» Kidney specialist's proposal smacks of exploitation
» Reward organ donors and give their families incentives
 
» Overseas transplants run risk of death & disease
 
 
 
ASIAONE POLL
Would you buy an organ to save your life?
Yes
No
I don't know
Read story
Search: