Iran deal wins praise, but next steps tougher

Iran deal wins praise, but next steps tougher
US Secretary of State Kerry speaks during a news conference following the E3/EU+3-Iran talks in Geneva

WASHINGTON - Analysts praised Washington's ground-breaking interim deal with Iran to rein in its nuclear programme in return for sanctions relief, but warned negotiations for a full agreement will prove even tougher.

"The interim deal is a strong one, which achieves a broader array of constraints and verification on Iran's nuclear programme than ever previously contemplated," said Suzanne Maloney, an Iran expert with the Brookings Institution.

She stressed that the six-month accord tied Tehran "to an ongoing diplomatic process whose primary rewards remain deferred until a far more ambitious agreement can be achieved."

After almost a decade of stalemate in negotiations between Iran and the so-called P5+1 group - Britain, China, France, Germany, Russia and the United States - things have moved at breakneck speed since Iran's President Hassan Rouhani took office in August and was hailed by some as a moderate.

Three rounds of negotiations since September led to a pre-dawn deal in Geneva.

"I think this has been a hard fought, effective and meaningful negotiation and has provided the kind of assurances that the negotiators need to have a legitimate, comprehensive discussion with Iran about the entirety of its nuclear progam," said Joel Rubin, director of policy for foundation the Ploughshares Fund.

The deal had put "time back on the clock" as the world tries to stop Iran getting to a so-called breakout capability where it could deploy a nuclear weapon, Rubin said, adding that Tehran's acceptance of daily inspections of by UN inspectors of its Natanz and Fordo plants was "unprecedented" as was an accord to stop work on its heavy water reactor at Arak.

"It's quite remarkable. If you had told me a few months ago that Iran would agree through diplomacy to eliminate its 20 per cent stockpile, to stop construction and any progress of Arak, to allow for intrusive and daily monitoring, I would tell you that that is an achievement for our security," Rubin told AFP.

But there was also a note of caution that the next round of negotiations towards a fully comprehensive deal could prove even tougher.

Kenneth Pollack, senior fellow for the Saban Center for Middle East Policy at Brookings, said it was "plausible" to think that Iran and the international community could now work out a full deal over the next six months, but "we should recognise that that step may prove far, far more difficult than the agreement just negotiated.

"The complexities are far greater. The concessions that both sides will be required to make will be far more painful," he cautioned.

More about

Purchase this article for republication.



Your daily good stuff - AsiaOne stories delivered straight to your inbox
By signing up, you agree to our Privacy policy and Terms and Conditions.