>> ASIAONE / NEWS / EDUCATION / STORY
Sat, Apr 24, 2010
The Straits Times
Modify uni admission system to let more succeed

I REFER to the recent letters on the admission of polytechnic graduates to local universities.

Many have referred to the seemingly unfair situation where junior college students are admitted with grades of Bs and Cs, while poly students need to be within the top 10 per cent of their cohort.

Related link:
» The best from polys can still enter local unis
» Qualifying for foreign uni not the same
» Increasing intake will not help
» Offer better answers to admissions squeeze
» Good enough for JC but chose poly
» Don't adopt 'them versus us' mentality

The underlying assumption in this is that both systems have similar standards. This is not entirely true as the A-level system still requires significant breadth, as can be seen by the contrasting subject requirements and the General Paper/Knowledge and Inquiry requirements. In comparison, polys focus on the modules needed in the discipline itself. This produces graduates of very different moulds from both systems.

I agree that poly students deserve consideration for uni places and in a level playing field that takes into account their skills. But they must understand that while they may have more knowledge than JC grads in their field of study, they have correspondingly received less general education and this is a handicap in the degree system.

Perhaps it is time to compare grads of both systems fairly by modifying the University Admissions Score system to cater to poly grads as well. This system should have weightage given to general education while offering credit to specialisation.

The recent proposal to couple liberal arts programmes with professional degrees is a tacit admission of the difficulties of getting people to undergo a broader general education. The JC system is one that achieves this aim and needs recognition of this often overlooked strength.

Lan Yingjie

This article was first published in The Straits Times.

 

 

Bookmark and Share
 
 
STORY INDEX
 
  SJI boy in hospital after judo match
   
 
  More protection for private school students with one-stop centre
   
 
  Ex-banker sets up centre for children with special needs
   
 
  Student cries foul over expulsion
   
 
  Mainland Chinese students to pay at least double in tuition
   
 
  MOE apologises over invite mix-up
   
 
  Good enough for JC but chose poly
   
 
  Modify uni admission system to let more succeed
   
 
  Offer better answers to admissions squeeze
   
 
  Increasing intake will not help
   
>> RELATED STORY
Offer better answers to admissions squeeze
Increasing intake will not help
Qualifying for foreign uni not the same
Lawmakers fight
Don't limit aspirations of poly students

Elsewhere in AsiaOne...

Motoring: Toyota sends university grads to factories

Digital: New e-test system for NUS students

Business: To MBA or not to MBA