The disruptive search for identity

The disruptive search for identity
The Brexit vote in Britain, Mr Donald Trump's election victory in the United States, the spate of terrorist attacks in Europe including the latest in Berlin and the continuing instability in the Middle East all point towards an uncertain future with many more upheavals to come.
PHOTO: AFP

Every individual, nation and society seeks to identify itself in some way that sets it apart from another.

For countries, this national identity is shaped by its history, the culture and tradition of its people, and their hopes and aspirations for the future.

But the speed of change in the modern world has disrupted the formation of these identities, changing or replacing them with new ones.

If you cannot wait to see the end of 2016, you are probably not alone. It has been a year of surprises, disappointments and shocks.

The Brexit vote in Britain, Mr Donald Trump's election victory in the United States, the spate of terrorist attacks in Europe including the latest in Berlin and the continuing instability in the Middle East all point towards an uncertain future with many more upheavals to come.

On the economic front, growth has not returned in many countries with too many people unemployed, wage levels stagnating and the gap between the rich and poor widening.

There is popular revolt in many places against the ill effects of globalisation, which is seen by many to benefit mainly the elite.

The political backlash has upended the established order in the US and the United Kingdom, and threatens to do so in several other European countries facing important elections next year.

The European Union's future is now more uncertain than it has ever been but even more unknown is what will take its place.

US-China relations look like they are entering a new period of uncertainty following Mr Trump's election.

Donald Trump wins US presidency in stunning upset

  • Open gallery

    Donald Trump has stunned America and the world, riding a wave of populist resentment to defeat Hillary Clinton in the race to become the 45th president of the United States.

  • Open gallery

    The Republican mogul defeated his Democratic rival, plunging global markets into turmoil and casting the long-standing global political order, which hinges on Washington's leadership, into doubt.

  • Open gallery

    "Now it is time for America to bind the wounds of division," Trump told a crowd of jubilant supporters in the early hours of Wednesday in New York.

  • Open gallery

    "I pledge to every citizen of our land that I will be president for all Americans." During a bitter two-year campaign that tugged at America's democratic fabric, the bombastic tycoon pledged to deport illegal immigrants, ban Muslims from the country and tear up free trade deals.

  • Open gallery

    His message appears to have been embraced by much of America's white majority, disgruntled by the breath and scope of social change and economic change in the last eight years under their first black president, Barack Obama.

  • Open gallery

    Trump openly courted Russian leader Vladimir Putin, called US support for NATO allies in Europe into question and suggested that South Korea and Japan should develop their own nuclear weapons.

  • Open gallery

    The businessman turned TV star turned-politico - who has never before held elected office - will become commander-in-chief of the world's sole true superpower on January 20.

  • Open gallery

    The results prompted a global market sell-off, with stocks plunging across Asia and Europe and billions being wiped off the value of investments.

  • Open gallery

    Although he has no government experience and in recent years has spent as much time running beauty pageants and starring in reality television as he had building his property empire, Trump at 70 will be the oldest man to ever become president.

  • Open gallery

    Yet, during his improbable rise, Trump has constantly proved the pundits and received political wisdom wrong.

  • Open gallery

    Opposed by the entire senior hierarchy of his own Republican Party, he trounced more than a dozen better-funded and more experienced rivals in the party primary.

  • Open gallery

    During the race, he was forced to ride out allegations of sexual assault and was embarrassed but apparently not shamed to have been caught on tape boasting about groping women.

  • Open gallery

    And, unique in modern US political history, he refused to release his tax returns.

  • Open gallery

    But the biggest upset came on Tuesday, as he swept to victory through a series of hard-fought wins in battleground states from Florida to Ohio.

  • Open gallery

    Clinton had been widely assumed to be on course to enter the history books as the first woman to become president in America's 240-year existence.

  • Open gallery

    Americans have repudiated her call for unity amid the United States' wide cultural and racial diversity, opting instead for a leader who insisted the country is broken and that "I alone can fix it."

  • Open gallery

    If early results hold out, Trump's party will have full control of Congress and he will be able to appoint a ninth Supreme Court justice to a vacant seat on the bench, deciding the balance of the body.

  • Open gallery

    So great was the shock that Clinton did not come out to her supporters' poll-watching party to concede defeat, but instead called Trump and sent her campaign chairman to insist in vain the result was too close to call.

  • Open gallery

    "I want every person in this hall to know, and I want every person across the country who supported Hillary to know that your voices and your enthusiasm mean so much to her and to him and to all of us. We are so proud of you. And we are so proud of her," chairman John Podesta told shell-shocked supporters.

  • Open gallery

    "She's done an amazing job, and she is not done yet," he insisted.

  • Open gallery

    Musician Lagy Gaga stages a protest against Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump on a sanitation truck outside Trump Tower in New York City after midnight on election day November 9, 2016.

  • Open gallery

    A street performer dressed as the Statue of Liberty hold photos of U.S. presidential candidates Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton at the financial Central district in Hong Kong, China November 9, 2016, after Trump won the presidency.

  • Open gallery

    A "Naked Cowboy" performer supporting Donald Trump walks through Times Square in New York, November 9, 2016.

  • Open gallery

    People react as they watch news on a screen to follow the results of the final day of the US presidential election at an event organised by the American consulate in Shanghai on November 9, 2016.

  • Open gallery

    Protesters against president-elect Donald Trump march peacefully through Oakland, California.

  • Open gallery

    A separate group earlier in the night set fire to garbage bins and smashed multiple windows.

  • Open gallery
  • Open gallery
  • Open gallery

    Police officers chase a group of about 50 protesters.

  • Open gallery

    University of California, Davis students protest on campus in Davis, California.

  • Open gallery

    An invitee places a cookie depicting U.S. Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton on a table at the US presidential election results watch party at the residence of US Ambassador to Japan, Caroline Kennedy, in Tokyo.

It is possible to conclude from all this that the world is heading towards some calamitous end and to wish for the return of saner times.

Be careful, though, what you wish for.

For all the perplexing turns and unpredictability, the changes taking place today and the upheavals they bring are nowhere near those that have taken place in the last century.

Two world wars have been fought, killing up to 100 million people and destroying entire cities, including two in Japan that were devastated by atomic bombs.

There were other wars that not only brought more deaths and destruction but also changed the geopolitical landscape dramatically: the civil war in China, in the Korean peninsula, in Vietnam and the Cold War between the US and the Soviet Union.

Read also: Singapore was aware of terror cell: Shanmugam

Terror strike in Singapore 'only a matter of time'

As for disruptive ideas that threaten to change our lives for better or worse, today's list - globalisation, the fourth industrial revolution, extremist ideology, to name a few - doesn't look as game-changing as the grand ideas of the past century that did change the world: the rise of communism in Russia and China, the anti-colonialist nationalist movements in China, India and South-east Asia, the trade union movement of the 20th century which entrenched workers' rights and the suffrage and feminist movements.

These were historical events which overturned the established political and social order, liberating millions of people, sometimes from physical oppression, but mostly in the way they changed human thinking and how people saw the world and their future.

On the technology front, today's digital revolution has been truly amazing but there have been equally revolutionary inventions in the past, including the discovery of electricity and the invention of the motor car and the internal combustion engine, airplanes and nuclear energy.

Can we really say the world we are living in today is more disruptive and unpredictable than in the past?

As we review the year and ponder what is in store the next, it is useful to do so taking a wider perspective and longer time horizon, and not be overwhelmed by the hype and exaggeration of the moment.

This isn't the most foreboding period in human history - not by a long shot.

But there are worrying trends common to many of the recent events that are worth watching because they will shape the course of human history.

Of these, one of the most important concerns the issue of identity.

Read also: Tharman: Reinforce multicultural identity

Every individual, nation and society seeks to identify itself in some way that sets it apart from another.

For countries, this national identity is shaped by its history, the culture and tradition of its people, and their hopes and aspirations for the future.

But the speed of change in the modern world has disrupted the formation of these identities, changing or replacing them with new ones.

This is disruptive because the old identities formed along traditional lines of culture, religion and language existed for long periods, resulting in stable and strong societies.

But globalisation and the digitally connected world fragmented these societies, enabling many people to identify with others inside and outside their countries with similar interests, setting them apart from others.

They take on multiple identities which might strengthen or weaken their attachment to their own national identity.

Read also: Here I Am: Actress Oon Shu An's powerful exploration of identity is a hit on social media

Many commentators, for example, have pointed out that America is a divided country, with many white voters in the recent election identifying with President-elect Trump while large numbers of non-white and urban voters are opposed to him.

Pro-Trump voters want to reclaim the identity they believe has been lost because of the actions and policies of the elites in Washington and want to "make America great again".

You could say the same for Britons who voted for the country to leave the EU. They too seek an identity that is not shaped by bureaucrats in Brussels.

Read also: Brexit, and how Singapore will be affected

Can the EU survive Brexit?

One outcome of the dislocation felt by many people as a result of their fragmented societies is to seek refuge in an earlier identity, often along race and religious lines.

Extremist terrorists exploit this, propagating their form of violent identity, to differentiate themselves from moderate Muslims and what they see as the decadence of the western world.

The crisis of identity experienced by so many people and countries is a signature theme of the post-modern world.

Everywhere, people are seeking answers to the questions: Who are we and where do we want to go?

Read also: What a Trump win means for Singapore

They have to answer the first question before they can answer the second.

Who you are determines where you want to go.

National identity isn't a static concept but changes continuously, and, according to many sociologists, is always contested, constructed and reconstructed.

That is a recipe for more disruptions.

The writer is also senior fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS), Nanyang Technological University.

This article first appeared in RSIS Commentary


This article was first published on Dec 29, 2016.
Get a copy of The Straits Times or go to straitstimes.com for more stories.

More about

Purchase this article for republication.
Your daily good stuff - AsiaOne stories delivered straight to your inbox
By signing up, you agree to our Privacy policy and Terms and Conditions.