'My fiance called off our engagement because he disliked the way I did housework'

'My fiance called off our engagement because he disliked the way I did housework'
Posed photo
PHOTO: The New Paper

"Dear Troubleshooter" is a relationship advice column that appears in The Japan News, a publication that is part of the Asia News Network.

Dear Troubleshooter,

I'm a female part-timer in my 20s. My boyfriend, whom I'd dated for six years, has broken off our engagement.

He explained he did not like the way I did housework during the two years we lived together. He also said he was under pressure as he had just gotten another job. He apologised to my parents by kneeling on the ground in front of them in the traditional dogeza style to express his sincerity.

I did the chores even while I myself was working, in an effort to create a problem-free life. I would tell him it's only natural for our ways of doing housework to differ since we come from different family backgrounds. I also said we needed to compromise and support each other. He insisted he could not stand living with me any more.

If we had had children, he probably would have severely reprimanded me over how I raised them, in addition to how I did the housework. So I'm now convinced it was right I did not marry him.

At the same time, whenever I recall our six years, I'm so disturbed that it's hard for me to fall asleep. I'm always thinking about him.

S, Saitama Prefecture

7 signs your relationship won't last

  • Open gallery

    Signs of a break up #1: Is the relationship turning mean?

  • Open gallery

    While "treat 'em mean, keep 'em keen" may sometimes attract that special person, if you've been with your loved one for a while and you're still being treated mean then it's unlikely that your partner's objective is to keep you keen.

  • Open gallery

    While most couples tease each other by being 'mean' in a playful/flirtatious way, if their main intention is to hurt or demean you then the respect has evaporated from the relationship and it's going to end in tears.

  • Open gallery

    Signs of a break up #2: You choose not to spend much time together. Relationships thrive when both members of a couple create the right balance between spending time apart and spending special time together.

  • Open gallery

    If you find yourself spending a large amount of time without your partner and you're not even missing them, there's a good chance you're just not that into them and your relationship is probably headed for the rocks.

  • Open gallery

    Signs of a break-up #3: You're not introduced to family or friends. When you've met that special someone who you really love, you have butterflies in your stomach and you want to shout about your romance from the rooftops.

  • Open gallery

    If you've been with someone for a good few months and they still haven't introduced you to their family or friends then you've got to question why they aren't making your relationship public information.

  • Open gallery

    Signs of a break-up #4: They're controlling. Does your other half want to know your exact whereabouts and exactly what you're up to at all times? While you might enjoy the attention to start off with, this can become pretty annoying after some time.

  • Open gallery

    Signs of a break-up #5: Where's the commitment? If you've been seeing each other for a while and your other half has shown no signs of wanting to commit, it's worth wondering why.

  • Open gallery

    Of course, some romances take a long time to develop by nature, but make sure you don't end up being strung along by someone who doesn't see a future with you.

  • Open gallery

    Signs of a break-up #6: You have nothing in common. Yes, we know that opposites attract but when you're so opposite that you can't even have a decent conversation because you have nothing in common, we're pretty sure that polar opposites repel.

  • Open gallery

    Of course, you don't want to be with someone who is exactly the same as you (yawn!) - having different interests can be exciting. When it gets to the point where your conversations are boring though, we can pretty confidently say that this isn't go

  • Open gallery

    A relationship where one person wants to commit and the other doesn't seem interested is destined for disaster.

  • Open gallery

    Signs of a break-up #7: Too busy to call. Of course, it's normal for people to be too busy to call their partner a lot of the time - life is busy! However, if the phrase "I'm too busy to call" is becoming all too familiar, then your other half....

  • Open gallery

    ...needs to prioritise. If they can't do that, you're going to end up feeling pretty rubbish. Everyone needs to feel special and if your other half doesn't make you feel that way, it's time to ditch them for someone who does!

Dear Ms. S,

I'm a bitter person who likes to let my imagination run wild, so please allow me to do so in regard to your issue. Honestly, your boyfriend wanted to break up with you for a long time and was worried about when he should tell you. Once he got another job and felt at ease, he at last moved on to tackling the next difficult matter: breaking off his engagement with you. He's already apologised to your parents properly, so he now probably enjoys a sense of freedom.

Why do you think you failed to notice he wasn't happy with you for such a long time? Our love for someone doesn't fade because we aren't satisfied with the person's way of doing housework.

You told him you both need to compromise and support each other in married life. But did you ever give way to his opinions or requests and make concessions? Did you ever support him, instead of just seeking mutual support? He may have given way to you and supported you more often than you thought. At least, he may have felt that way.

In any case, you should not cry out, "Give me back my six years!" Instead, recognise that it was good for you to live with him. You probably had some fun times with him and learned something you couldn't have otherwise. You should think of yourself as indebted to him for the life you have now.

I hope you will live a new life from now on while keeping this meaningful experience in mind. Instead of having him in your future, you have the possibility of meeting someone better than him. In this respect, you have been freed as well.

Hazuki Saisho, writer

More about

Your daily good stuff - AsiaOne stories delivered straight to your inbox
By signing up, you agree to our Privacy policy and Terms and Conditions.