Sex trafficking on American Indian reservations - old problem, new name

Sex trafficking on American Indian reservations - old problem, new name
Tribal elder Tommy Christian, who lives on Montana's Fort Peck Indian Reservation, speaks at an anti-trafficking conference at the Fort Peck Community College in Montana, April 28, 2016.
PHOTO: Reuters

POPLAR, MONTANA - A victims' advocate on the Fort Peck Indian Reservation figures she first saw sex trafficking more than a decade ago, a local nurse says it happened in her own family and a women's counselor is sure she has seen it countless times.

But while it was sex trafficking, it had no name, they say.

Law enforcement, advocates and residents of Fort Peck, a vast, remote reservation of windswept plains in the US state of Montana, say they have been seeing cases of sex trafficking for years without labeling them as such.

Tribal law at Fort Peck only added sex trafficking as a distinct crime earlier this year, distinguishing it from rape, sexual abuse or kidnapping, experts say.

Public awareness of the crime is critical, say activists who held a conference last month on recognising trafficking on the reservation.

"We have to acknowledge and say that sex trafficking is happening in our communities," said Toni Plummer-Alvernaz, executive director of the Montana Native Women's Coalition and a conference organizer.

"Native women are trafficking their relatives. People are often trading their bodies for drugs," she said.

Coleen Clark estimates she has counseled some 8,000 victims of violence during her three decades working at the Red Bird Women's Center in Wolf Point, the reservation's largest town with a population of fewer than 3,000 residents.

"When I look back through those years, I can see where some of those women were victims of human trafficking," Clark said.

"But we didn't have a name for that then. There was not a whole lot of public awareness."

Even now, numbers don't tell the story, and there is little in the way of statistics to quantify what experts, advocates and authorities say is happening.

"Based on our investigation of trafficking on Fort Peck, the scope of the problem is far larger than any information we have so far in terms of statistics would reflect," said Melina Healey, a trafficking expert at the Child Law Policy and Legislation Clinic at Loyola University Chicago.

She helped write the tribal law against trafficking.

Updating the law with trafficking will help in efforts to collect data and "demonstrate to the community and to other governments, to the public at large that there's a problem here and it's reaching crisis levels," she said.

"The popular idea of what sex trafficking involves often is people chained to a basement, Russian women brought over to this country in container ships and sold into slavery," Healey said. "But sex trafficking doesn't look like that most of the time."

It can simply involve a person being exploited for sex, someone buying the sex and someone else orchestrating the deal, she said.

"There's no movement across borders or physical confinement necessary," she said.


Evidence of trafficking on the Fort Peck reservation won't be found in federal statistics, said Cyndee Peterson, an assistant US Attorney in Montana who heads up a task force teaching law enforcement and attorneys to recognise trafficking.

Records, she said, do not show federal prosecutors handling any trafficking cases on Fort Peck going back five years.

"How do we know these cases are here? Because the advocates that actually are on the ground talking to the victims are telling me," she told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.

"Don't look at our numbers and think that it's not happening," she said. "People did not know what they were seeing."

Now, she said, after every training session held by her task force, a law enforcement officer will approach her and say: "You know what? I actually have had trafficking cases in the past and I didn't recognise it as trafficking."

Tribal elder Tommy Christian, a member of the Fort Peck tribes' executive board, blames some of the lack of evidence to Indian problems falling on deaf ears in the white community.

"I think it's just an attitude of well, we're all savages and it's just another dead Indian," he said.

Twenty-five years after her half-brother was sent to prison, Tami Adams-Martens, 59, a nurse at Poplar Hospital, said she now realises the case involved trafficking.

Her stepsister had been hooked on crack cocaine and in debt to a dealer but had no money, she said.

"(The dealer) said, 'Look, somebody is going to get hurt if you don't pay up. Do you have anything else I want?' and she said, 'Well, I've got a 13-year-old daughter,'" she said.

A fight broke out, and the dealer was killed by Adams-Martens's half-brother who stepped in to block the deal, she said. He spend 17 years in prison.

"I didn't realise it was trafficking," she said, adding: "I think everyone here has a story like that or is very close to a story like that."


Joni Johnson, who helps crime victims on the reservation, works with two young women who have suffered domestic violence, are drug users and who she is certain are trading sex for drugs.

"They don't realise when they're doing, but it is human trafficking," she said.

A more haunting case was some 15 years ago when a sexual assault victim revealed that she was selling her nieces for drugs, she said.

"There just wasn't a name for it," she said.

Name or not, the problem stretches far back in time, Clark said.

"We could go back to the day that the settlers came, the day that fur trappers came, those days when colonisation hit and demeaned the significance and honour and sacredness of women and children," she said.

More about

Your daily good stuff - AsiaOne stories delivered straight to your inbox
By signing up, you agree to our Privacy policy and Terms and Conditions.