Harvey Weinstein motives are disputed as sex crimes retrial begins

Harvey Weinstein motives are disputed as sex crimes retrial begins
Harvey Weinstein, former co-chairman of the Weinstein Co., at Manhattan criminal court in New York, US, on Monday, April 21, 2025.
PHOTO: Michael Nagle via Reuters

NEW YORK — Harvey Weinstein's retrial on rape and sexual assault charges got underway on Wednesday (April 23), as a prosecutor and a defence lawyer offered starkly contrasting explanations for the disgraced movie mogul's encounters with women who hoped to make it big in Hollywood.

Prosecutor Shannon Lucey told jurors in a New York state court in Manhattan that Weinstein exploited his status as a Hollywood gatekeeper and power broker to prey upon and sexually abuse women, then assured their silence by holding their careers hostage.

"Harvey Weinstein had enormous control over those working in TV and film because he decided who was in and who was out," Lucey said in her opening statement. "He had all the power. They had none."

Prosecutors have portrayed Weinstein as a serial predator who promised career advancement in Hollywood to women, only to then coax them into hotel rooms and private apartments where he overpowered and attacked them.

Weinstein's lawyer Arthur Aidala rejected that characterisation, saying the Oscar-winning producer had "mutually beneficial" relationships with his accusers, who ended up with auditions and other show business opportunities.

"They realised very quickly: Harvey Weinstein, he's got the key to that room where they all want to go," Aidala said in his opening statement, referring to career advancement.

Weinstein, 73, dressed in a dark suit and navy tie, listened after being brought into the courtroom in a wheelchair.

Harvey Weinstein, former co-chairman of the Weinstein Co., at Manhattan criminal court in New York, US, on Monday, April 21, 2025. 
PHOTO: Michael Nagle via Reuters

He has pleaded not guilty to two counts of first-degree criminal sexual act and one count of third-degree rape, and could face decades in prison if convicted. Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg was in attendance as the retrial began.

#MeToo

Weinstein is being retried one year after New York's highest court overturned his 2020 rape and sexual assault conviction and 23-year prison sentence, citing errors by the trial judge.

The conviction had been a milestone for the #MeToo movement, which encouraged women to come forward with allegations of sexual misconduct by powerful men.

More than 100 women, including famous actresses, have accused Weinstein of misconduct. He has denied assaulting anyone or having non-consensual sex.

Weinstein co-founded the Miramax studio, whose hit movies included Shakespeare in Love and Pulp Fiction.

His own eponymous film studio filed for bankruptcy in March 2018, five months after the original sexual misconduct accusations became widely publicised.

The new trial before state Supreme Court Justice Curtis Farber is expected to last about six weeks. Farber did not handle the original trial.

New charge

In ordering a retrial, the state Court of Appeals last April said Weinstein's first trial had been unfair because the judge let women testify that Weinstein assaulted them, even though their accusations were not the basis for criminal charges.

Bragg's office is again accusing Weinstein of sexually assaulting former production assistant Miriam Haley in 2006 and raping aspiring actress Jessica Mann in 2013, charges he was convicted of in the first trial.

For the retrial, prosecutors added a new charge that Weinstein assaulted another woman in Manhattan in 2006.

Prosecutor Shannon Lucey points to former film producer Harvey Weinstein before Supreme Court Justice Curtis Farber during opening statements as his retrial on rape and sexual assault charges got underway at Manhattan Criminal Court, in New York City, US, April 23, 2025 in a courtroom sketch. 
PHOTO: Reuters

Lucey said that woman is Kaja Sokola, from Poland, who claims Weinstein assaulted her when she was a 16-year-old aspiring actress.

Even if he is acquitted, Weinstein will likely spend the rest of his life in prison because he was convicted of sex crimes in California and was sentenced to a 16-year term.

Weinstein has had several health scares while being held in New York City's Rikers Island jail, and in September was rushed to a hospital for emergency heart surgery.

Citing his health, Weinstein's lawyers are seeking a court order to let him stay overnight at Bellevue Hospital in Manhattan for the duration of the trial.

Weinstein's representatives have said he has received inadequate medical care at Rikers.

Lindsay Goldbrum, a lawyer representing Sokola, in a statement said the retrial "will test how far we've advanced in our collective understanding of sexual assault, power dynamics, and what it means to be a survivor."

Read Also
entertainment
Harvey Weinstein pleads not guilty to committing a criminal sexual act

Source: Reuters

homepage

trending

trending
    Spurs captain Son says he is leaving the club
    'It was so gross': Man left disgusted after finding maggots in meal at Hougang restaurant
    Man allegedly spotted vaping on bus wearing military uniform was held in SAF custody
    Chinese EV brand JMEV officially launches in Singapore with the Elight sedan
    27-year-old who helps run family's hawker business opens own restaurant: 'I should maximise what I can do at this age'
    Australian man, 82, arrested for alleged March thefts at Changi Airport upon return to Singapore  
    Gossip mill: Seventeen's Mingyu in Singapore for event, Babymonster's Chiquita receives hate presumably over Thai nationality, Jeon Somi recounts long chat with ghost
    Malaysia tourism group says LTA crackdown on illegal cross-border ride services at Changi Airport 'inconveniences travellers'
    Support local: FairPrice launches farmers market with Singapore-grown produce, includes exclusive plushies and more
    Edwin Goh and Rachel Wan's wedding to be for next year: 'There's still a lot of things we need to figure out'
    28 arrested, luxury cars seized during anti-vice raids
    JB car wash operators say 'unfair' after business declines amid govt clampdown over prioritising Singapore-registered cars

Singapore

Singapore
    • Tanjong Katong Road South repair works completed, to reopen in phases from Aug 2: LTA, PUB
    • Safeguards in place to deter fraudulent injury claims at workplace: MOM
    • PM Lawrence Wong to deliver National Day message on Aug 8
    • $12.8m Toto jackpot won by single ticket bought online
    • New vehicular bridge connecting Punggol Central and Seletar Link to open on Aug 3
    • SGH medical team comes home after Dhaka mission to help treat burn victims from fighter jet crash
    • Part-time PHV driver who stopped suicide attempt among 38 recipients of MHA’s public spiritedness award
    • Tan Kiat How 'heartened' as vape disposal bin in Bedok half-filled in just 4 days
    • Man accused of raping woman who hired him to fix lights in her flat claims she made first move
    • 'Proud of what they've done': Jetstar Asia CEO expresses gratitude to crew on airline's final day of operations

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • E-Junkies: J-pop group Psychic Fever talk global goals and new EP
    • 'I'm happy taking the audience seat': Andrew Seow, now auxiliary police officer, reflects on past acting career
    • Blackpink's Rose has a Singapore pop-up where you can recreate APT music video and pick up merch
    • Cha Eun-woo's Memories VR concert: Become his 'girlfriend' in romantic fantasy show
    • Hulk Hogan never met grandkids before his death
    • Gary Busey pleads guilty to groping woman at horror film convention
    • Blake Lively accused of harassment and intimidation
    • Miley Cyrus has special plans for Hannah Montana's 20th anniversary
    • Hulk Hogan secretly battled blood cancer before his death
    • Justin Timberlake diagnosed with 'relentlessly debilitating' Lyme disease

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • I try 11 new Michelin Bib Gourmand 2025 eateries to see if they're worth the hype, here's my honest take
    • Bak kut teh ramen, laksa shakshuka and chilli crab burgers: Celebrate National Day with these exclusive SG60 meals
    • Japanese restaurant Umi Nami to shutter, in yet another F&B business closure at Holland Village
    • Uniqlo launching T-shirt collection in collab with Pokemon Trading Card Game
    • These 2 islands share the same name, with totally different vibes: Japan's Cat Island versus Chill Beach Town
    • Best seats in the house: Where to feast, toast and watch the NDP 2025 fireworks
    • How 2 Singaporeans power the NDP moment that gives us goosebumps
    • Sierra Leone chimp refuge shuts doors to tourists to protest deforestation
    • A slice of America: Corvette makes its long-awaited debut in Singapore
    • Michelin-starred restaurant Alma by Juan Amador to shutter in August, plans to reopen with new concept

Digicult

Digicult
    • Slim, sleek, but slightly too short-lived: Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge review
    • World's best Dota 2 teams to compete for $1m prize pool in Singapore in November
    • Sony RX1R III brings back the compact full-frame but not the Sony playbook
    • China's Premier Li proposes global AI co-operation organisation
    • 'They don't gaslight you': Why some Singaporean women like to spend on these virtual men
    • Elon Musk's Starlink network suffers rare global outage
    • Spy cockroaches and AI robots: Germany plots the future of warfare
    • 'Give a positive review': Hidden AI prompt found in academic paper by NUS researchers
    • 'Report 1 shop, another 10 appear': Hoyo Fest artists on copyright struggles
    • NTU penalises 3 students over use of AI tools; they dispute university's findings

Money

Money
    • Up 4.3%: Singapore's economy grew in Q2 despite US tariff fears
    • Should you buy a used car in Singapore? Pros, pitfalls and price comparisons
    • Why I bought 7 properties in Johor Bahru, and will still buy more
    • Trump says US will set 15% tariff on South Korean imports under new deal
    • Cathay Cineplexes operator mm2 hires debt restructuring specialist as it faces more payment demands; CEO Chang Long Jong to retire
    • 6 best travel insurance plans in Singapore (July 2025)
    • How to claim travel insurance? A comprehensive beginner's guide (2025)
    • Britain and India sign free trade pact during Modi visit
    • Long-time tech executive and Microsoft Singapore managing director Lee Hui Li dies
    • HDB launches 10,209 BTO and balance flats, as priority scheme for singles kick in

Latest

Latest
  • Ghislaine Maxwell moved to prison camp, Trump says no plea for pardon
  • How Gaza exasperation pushed 3 Israel allies towards recognising Palestinian state
  • South Korea says it has no written pact on US trade deal
  • UK ninja sword ban begins as 1,000 weapons surrendered in knife crime crackdown
  • Thailand returns some Cambodian soldiers ahead of key border talks
  • South Korea's ex-leader Yoon lay on floor of cell and refused to be questioned, prosecutors say
  • Cambodia to nominate Donald Trump for Nobel Peace Prize, says deputy PM
  • Putin, facing Trump deadline, signals no change in Russia's stance on Ukraine
  • Musk's X must face part of lawsuit over child pornography video

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • Discrimination and bias less likely than violence and insults to be viewed as unacceptable conduct between races: AsiaOne poll
  • 3-room and bigger Tampines, Toa Payoh BTO flats most popular with first-timers in July HDB launch
  • 'Count his lucky stars': Youth struck by taxi while dashing across Yio Chu Kang Road, netizens react
  • Tanjong Katong sinkhole: ItsRainingRaincoats raises $72,000 within 2 days for migrant workers who rescued woman
  • Tanjong Katong sinkhole: It should not have happened, says Grace Fu as panel convened to probe incident
  • Love scam: Man transfers $120k to online 'China girlfriend' of 2 years after sale of Ang Mo Kio flat
  • Toddler wanders out of home in Selangor, mauled by stray dogs
  • Mid-air brawl erupts on AirAsia X flight from KL to Chengdu over loud conversation
  • Robber drops gun and misfires after failed clinic robbery in JB
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.