Award Banner
Award Banner

Woman's ovaries mistakenly removed during womb surgery at Hong Kong hospital

Woman's ovaries mistakenly removed during womb surgery at Hong Kong hospital
The Chinese University of Hong Kong Medical Centre said a nurse discovered during a post-surgery specimen check that both ovaries had been accidentally removed, and immediately alerted the surgeon.
PHOTO: Pexels

A 45-year-old woman in Hong Kong had both her ovaries mistakenly removed during an operation that was supposed to remove only her uterus and fallopian tubes.

The incident occurred in September at the Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK) Medical Centre, a private teaching hospital in Sha Tin.

According to the South China Morning Post (SCMP), the hospital apologised on Tuesday (Nov 17) after the incident was disclosed by the Department of Health in its monthly list of sentinel events at private hospitals.

The hospital attributed the mistake to a "cognitive lapse" and a temporary loss of focus by the surgeon, who has not been publicly identified.

Nurse discovered mistake during specimen check

The operation, a laparoscopic hysterectomy and bilateral salpingectomy, was performed on Sept 12 after the patient was diagnosed with a suspected endometrial abnormality, CNA reported.

Both the surgical consent form and the original treatment plan had explicitly stated that her ovaries were to be preserved.

However, the mistake was discovered only after the surgical specimens were removed. A nurse checking the specimens found that both ovaries had been included and immediately alerted the surgeon that this was inconsistent with the planned procedure.

In a statement, CUHK Medical Centre said its investigation found that the surgeon had become highly focused on carrying out the immediate clinical steps, resulting in a temporary loss of situational awareness.

The surgeon acknowledged the mistake and apologised to the patient and her family.

The hospital said it took the doctor's individual responsibility seriously and would impose disciplinary action in accordance with its human resources policies.

It also said it had conducted a comprehensive review and would introduce improvements, including clear visual prompts during surgery to help the medical team follow the planned procedure.

Patient in stable condition, says health department

According to CNA, the hospital said the patient was in stable condition and would continue receiving medical follow-up and support. The Department of Health received a report of the incident from the hospital on Sept 13.

It said there was no evidence that the hospital had breached requirements concerning its premises, staffing or equipment under the relevant code of practice in connection with the incident.

The Standard reported that the department had completed its investigations into the accident and would continue monitoring the corrective measures implemented by the institutions involved.

Separately, obstetrics and gynaecology specialist Dr Yu Kai-man told a radio programme, as reported by CNA, that the ovaries and fallopian tubes would not normally be mistaken for one another due to differences in their shape, colour and position.

However, he noted that adhesions, where scar-like tissue causes internal organs to stick together, could make it more difficult to distinguish them during surgery.

[[nid:745082]]

asyiqin.nadzri@asiaone.com

For more original AsiaOne articles, visit here.
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.