Do women need to save more for retirement than men?

PHOTO: Unsplash
We hate to start this on a downer, but did you know that you and I will literally never see the day women and men are paid equally worldwide?
 
According to the World Economic Forum’s Global Gender Gap Report 2021, the economic gender gap is going to take a whopping 267.6 years to close!
 
But just because we likely won’t see it happen in our time, doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t challenge the status quo—in fact, it’s more reason that we do. 
Economic inequality between men and women is driven by various factors, like men being employed in higher paying industries and positions than women, uneven access to education, and more.

But have you ever thought about how such economic inequality also affects retirement?

What does the economic gender gap mean for a woman’s financial security in her golden years?

We take a deep dive into economic gender inequality and assess if women need to save more for retirement than men.

1. Women earn lower pay than men

Like many other countries in the world, Singapore is beset with a gender pay gap.

This refers to the difference between how much men earn and how much women earn.

In Singapore, women earn 16.3 per cent less than men, based on a 2018 study by MOM.

That means if the average Singaporean man earns $5,000 each month, his female counterpart earns $4,185.

Thus, for the same number of working years, women on average will earn less than men and find themselves with less money saved in the bank when they hit their retirement years.

That’s a big reason (if not the biggest) why women need to save more now to ensure they have enough savings later during their twilight years. 

But why do women in Singapore earn less than men anyway?

Let’s take a closer look at the factors that go into this 16.3 per cent difference in pay: 

GRAPHIC: Report on Singapore’s Adjusted Gender Pay Gap, 2018—Ministry of Manpower (2020)

Hold up, why does the gender pay gap get “adjusted” to six per cent?

Basically, this is how we explain why the gap exists. MOM looks at human capital factors like age and education, as well as labour market factors like occupation, industry, and usual hours worked per week.

Technically, the adjusted gender pay gap of six per cent is a more accurate reflection of whether men and women of comparable age, education, occupation, industry, and usual hours worked earn an equal pay.

In other words, it answers the question, “Does equal work mean equal pay for men and women?”

A small adjusted pay gap is good news—women and men are paid equally for the same work.

But if the small adjusted gap is accompanied by a large unadjusted one, that could point to an unequal representation of women and men in high-paying industries or positions. 

For example, if we look at high-paying positions, Deloitte reported that 13.1 per cent of CEOs and 33.7 per cent of CFOs in Singapore in 2021 were women.

(Singapore actually boasts the highest number of female CEOs in the world!) If male and female CEOs of similar work experience in the same industry receive similar pay, we’d see a small adjusted gender pay gap.

But the fact that there are more male CEOs than female ones overall might contribute to a larger unadjusted gap, especially for such a high-paying position. 

In MOM’s 2020 report, the 16.3 per cent unadjusted gap gets whittled down to a six per cent adjusted one.

That means we can explain 10.3 per cent-points of the pay discrepancy between men and women in Singapore; this portion of the gap reflects unequal work, not unequal pay for the same work.

Of the 10.3 per cent, occupational differences are the biggest factor.

We can attribute seven per cent-points to the types of jobs that men vs women have, differences in the pay across their jobs, or a combination of both. 

On the flipside, if we can explain 10.3 per cent of the gender pay gap, that also means we don’t know why the remaining six per cent gap exists.

Read Also
Cost of living in Singapore 2022: How much salary to live comfortably here?
Cost of living in Singapore 2022: How much salary to live comfortably here?

This gap means that even when a man and a woman of similar career levels do the same job, the woman earns six per cent less.

MOM suggests we might be able to attribute this six per cent to, “unmeasured employment characteristics (e.g. type of firms, position within firm, and work experience), caregiving responsibilities, parenthood, and labour market discrimination.” 

We’re covering caregiving responsibilities and parenthood reasons in our next section, but discrimination at work can be talked about now.

While the majority of companies in Singapore give equal opportunities to women, there are probably still a few offshoots contributing to a portion of Singapore’s six per cent adjusted pay gap.

Gendered workplace discrimination is an unfair employment practice, and is one of the reasons the Tripartite Alliance for Fair & Progressive Employment Practices (TAFEP) was set up.

If it happens to you or someone you know, don’t hesitate to report any gender discrimination to TAFEP — let’s take that six per cent down.

2. Women work fewer years than men

Generally speaking, women work for fewer years in their lifetime than men.

In Singapore, the labour force participation rate for women is 76.2 per cent compared to 89.6 per cent for men, as reported in MOM’s Labour Force in Singapore Advance Release 2022. 

That means lower lifetime savings, which in turn leads to lower retirement funds.

Why do women work less in their lifetime than men?

Read Also
A guide to the Working Mother's Child Relief (WMCR) scheme
A guide to the Working Mother's Child Relief (WMCR) scheme

According to MOM’s Labour Force in Singapore Advance Release 2022, among the women aged 40 and up who were re-entering the workforce, most cited taking a break or caring for their family as the main reasons they stopped working. 

Mindsets and perceptions appear to play a big role in skewing the caregiver role at home.

In a survey of 500 married Singaporeans, Ipsos and United Women Singapore found that 32 per cent of women and 41 per cent of men in Singapore agreed that in a marriage, it’s the husband’s main job to work and support his family, and the wife’s job to look after the household. 

The good news, however, is that the survey also found that these mindsets are changing for the better with each generation.

We all know women and men are equally entitled to work, and women shouldn’t be pigeonholed into a gender role at home that makes them sacrifice their career.

3. Women are found to be less financially informed than men

Globally, 35 per cent of men versus 30 per cent of women are financially literate, according to a study conducted in 2017 by the Global Financial Literacy Excellence Center.

In Singapore, a study conducted by professors at Singapore Management University (SMU) in 2020 showed that older women know less about finance than men, especially when it comes to stock diversification.

Women are also less concerned about how they’ll cope financially after they retire.

While there are always exceptions, financial savviness is typically associated with greater wealth and retirement readiness.

Being more familiar with the workings of the stock market and retirement annuity plans means one is probably in a better spot to grow their wealth and plan their retirement well. 

In fact, the 2020 SMU study we mentioned above found that being able to answer just one additional financial literacy question correctly meant an additional $166,800 in a person’s total net wealth, $97,700 in non-housing net wealth, and $52,600 in net financial wealth.

Thankfully, things are looking up. More and more women are taking financial and retirement planning into their own hands.

Fidelity International reported in 2022 that almost three in five women actively make their own investment and savings decisions, and 53 per cent had their own savings.

In the inaugural MasterCard Worldwide Index of Financial Literacy, Singaporean women ranked 5th out of 12 countries in Asia/Pacific for their financial knowledge.

When it comes to financial literacy, Singaporean women are on the way up.

4. Women live longer than men

This is a fight Singaporean women win the moment they’re born: the life expectancy at birth for Singaporean females is a ripe old 85.9 years as of 2021.

For men, this is 81.1 years, meaning women in Singapore live almost five years more than men on average. 

Now that we’ve told you the good news, we have to break the bad news: Living longer also means needing more money for retirement.

This widens our gender retirement gap even further.

Read Also
CPF LIFE vs Retirement Sum Scheme: What's the difference?
CPF LIFE vs Retirement Sum Scheme: What's the difference?

We know what you’re thinking: Doesn’t CPF LIFE cover everyone’s retirement no matter how long you live, male or female?

Well, yes. When it comes to CPF LIFE, its name is its virtue, and it does give all Singaporeans monthly retirement payouts for life.

The problem isn’t if you’ve covered, but by how much.

Let’s do a quick recap. The amount you get each month for your CPF LIFE payouts depends on how much you’ve saved in your CPF Retirement Account (RA) by the time you turn 65.

The fatter your RA, the higher your CPF LIFE payouts. 

If you have $60,000 in your RA when you turn 65, you’ll only receive $350-$370 each month — barely enough to get by.

You’d need to have saved $184,400 to cross the $1,000 payout mark, and have $428,300 in savings to receive at least $2,140 to $2,300 per month.

This is the problem: Not all of us will have enough saved in our RA by the time we turn 65 to receive monthly payouts sufficient to live on.

Especially not women who earn lower salaries and work fewer years. 

One might argue that CPF LIFE is just the base layer of your multi-layered retirement portfolio, and that’s 100 per cent true.

You’ll also need annuities and income-generating investments like rental income, dividends, and bonds for your retirement.

But if women are also less financially informed, they’ll be less likely to beef up their retirement portfolio and grow their money through investments.

If CPF LIFE is all they have, that’s not a lot to live on.

5. So, do women in Singapore need to save more for retirement than men?

Women in Singapore are more likely to need to save more for retirement than men if they earn less, work less, invest less and live longer.

Read Also
6 retirement planning mistakes to avoid
6 retirement planning mistakes to avoid

But that’s a lot of if’s. Though more probable statistically, that isn’t to say all women are guaranteed to take home lower salaries or leave their jobs to look after the household.

A woman’s personal choice counts for more than any number on a page, and there’s plenty of room for antiquated mindsets that assume gendered roles to change.

Increasingly, there’s also no reason for women to be financially less informed than men, and we can’t wait for the day this becomes a question so obsolete no one would even think to ask.

Furthermore, Singapore’s been making good progress in some key areas of the economic gender gap.

From 2002 to 2018, we narrowed the adjusted gender pay gap from 8.8 per cent to six per cent.

It’s now lower than that in other developed countries like China (18.3per cent), Canada (7.7-8.3 per cent) and the US (eight per cent), where the gender pay gap has remained pretty much unchanged for the past two decades.

As for quashing gender stereotypes, awareness is key.

And bit by bit, we’re seeing the needle move. For example, Ipsos and United Women Singapore found that younger couples below 35 years old are more likely to share household responsibilities.

While 28 per cent of married women between 35-44 years of age reported they share cleaning tasks at home, 38 per cent of married women below 35 years old said the same.

So while the question we asked was if women in Singapore need to save more for retirement than men, its answer asks another question: Can we narrow Singapore’s economic gender inequality?

Reducing the gender pay gap, putting female caregiver stereotypes to rest, and increasing financial literacy among women is possible.

Both genders can work to get there, one generation at a time.

PHOTO: Unsplash

This article was first published in MoneySmart.