Award Banner
Award Banner

Red meat is back on the menu, if a new review of its risks is to be believed

Red meat is back on the menu, if a new review of its risks is to be believed

LONDON - Cutting back on red and processed meat brings few if any health benefits, according to a review of studies involving millions of people, a finding that contradicts dietary advice of leading international agencies and raised immediate objections from many health experts.

Most people can continue to eat red and processed meat at current average intake, typically three or four times a week for adults in North America and Europe, said a study's authors, who also made new recommendations based on the analysis.

"Based on the research, we cannot say with any certainty that eating red or processed meat causes cancer, diabetes or heart disease," said Bradley Johnson, an associate professor at Dalhousie University in Canada who co-led the review published on Monday in the Annals of Internal Medicine journal.

However, in what amounts to a scientific food fight, a group of doctors from Harvard, Yale, Stanford and elsewhere, including one of the study authors, requested in a letter to the journal that it "pre-emptively retract publication" of the papers pending further review, and said revised guidelines that could lead to increased consumption of red and processed meats would be irresponsible.

A statement scheduled for publication by the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, shared with Reuters by Dr. Frank Hu, chair of the Department of Nutrition, said, "from a public health point of view, it is irresponsible and unethical to issue dietary guidelines that are tantamount to promoting meat consumption, even if there is still some uncertainty about the strength of the evidence."

Dr. David Katz, director of the Yale-Griffin Prevention Research Center at the Yale University School of Medicine, cited "grave concerns about the potential for damage to public understanding, and public health."

The World Health Organisation's International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) and the World Cancer Research Fund (WCRF) both say red and processed meat may or can cause cancer.

PHOTO: Reuters

The WCRF advises eating only "moderate amounts" of red meat, such as beef, pork and lamb - with an upper limit of 500 grams (17.6 ounces) cooked weight per week - and "little, if any" processed meat.

A panel of experts writing in The Lancet in January outlined an "ideal diet" for human health and the planet that said global average red meat consumption should be cut by 50 per cent and consumption of nuts, fruits, vegetables and legumes should double.

Read Also
health
Increasing red meat intake may also increase the risk of death: Study

For the latest analysis, researchers from Canada, Spain and Poland conducted a series of reviews of both randomized controlled trials and observational studies looking at the possible health impact of eating red and processed meat.

Among the randomized trials they selected for analysis, which included around 54,000 people, they found no statistically significant link between eating meat and the risk of heart disease, diabetes, or cancer.

Among the observational studies, which covered millions of people, they did find "a very small reduction in risk" in those who ate three fewer servings of red or processed meat a week, but said that this association "was very uncertain."

BEST APPROACH

"Our bottom line recommendation ... is that for the majority of people, but not everyone, continuing their red and processed meat consumption is the best approach," Johnson said.

Some experts not directly involved with the reviews said the work was a comprehensive, well-conducted analysis of the available evidence on eating meat and human health.

"This study will, I hope, help to eliminate the incorrect impression ... that some meat products are as carcinogenic as cigarette smoke, and to discourage dramatic media headlines claiming that 'bacon is killing us'," said Ian Johnson, a nutrition expert at Britain's Quadram Institute of bioscience.

Christine Laine, editor in chief of Annals of Internal Medicine, noted that nutrition studies are challenging as they are usually not randomized controlled trials and often depend on participants' memories.

PHOTO: Reuters 

"There may be lots of reasons to decrease meat in your diet, but if you're decreasing it to improve your health, we don't have a lot of strong evidence to support that," Laine said.

"To be honest with our patients and the public, we shouldn't be making recommendations that sound like they're based on solid evidence."

Quadram's Johnson said people who choose to cut down their meat intake might still improve their health by doing so.

"There are (also) strong environmental and ethical arguments for reducing meat consumption in the modern world." 

Eating more plant-based foods can help to reduce emissions of carbon dioxide, scientists say.

homepage

trending

trending
    US halts new student visa appointments - what now for students from Singapore?
    'I made a fool of myself': Malaysian woman trying to buy G-Dragon concert tickets accidentally buys ones for Kenny G
    Cones with reflective discs: More safety measures during peak hour at Woodlands Checkpoint after accident
    1.2 tonnes of illegally imported fresh and processed produce seized at Tuas Checkpoint
    In a first, NParks trials use of dead bird effigies to prevent crows from congregating
    Uncovering the secrets behind Chagee’s best-selling jasmine green milk tea
    13 men suspected of being members of unlawful societies arrested in island-wide operation
    Zhang Zhenhuan's daughter, 3, tries out acting, gets visit to Shanghai Disneyland as reward
    Revealing 4th cancer diagnosis, Law Kar Ying says he's at peace with death
    Made in Singapore: First locally-made Kia, the EV5, officially launched
    What to do this weekend (May 30 to June 1)
    South Korean actor Park Bo-gum to hold Singapore fan meeting in August

Singapore

Singapore
    • Non-life-threatening calls to 995 will be referred to triage helpline in nation-wide trial from June 1
    • Israel may be in breach of international law by restricting aid to Gaza: PM Wong
    • 'Your cue to show some care': LTA rolls out new Helping Hand card for commuters who need more assistance
    • 'We couldn't believe our eyes': Tourist charged $200 cleaning fee for eating durian in Singapore hotel room
    • Fire breaks out at Ubi coffee shop, 1 taken to hospital
    • Daily roundup: Fewer private university grads find full-time jobs in 2024, compared to 2023 — and other top stories today
    • Jalan Kayu SMC, Punggol GRC form new town councils
    • French President Macron and PM Wong sample local fare at Lau Pa Sat; sign deals on defence, AI at summit
    • 'We will sue him until he goes bankrupt': Victim's mother plans to sue ex-actor Ian Fang
    • 'We couldn't just stand by and do nothing': Samaritans recount helping after Braddell Road accident

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • Netflix responds to allegations of When Life Gives You Tangerines' extras being subjected to starvation and mistreatment
    • Gossip mill: Henry Lau welcomed by fans at Changi Airport, Cha Eun-woo and Rowoon to enlist in July
    • Zheng Geping gets surprise birthday celebration on drama set
    • Grab exclusive Dylan Wang merchandise with Chagee's upcoming Longjing Milk Tea series
    • Jenna Ortega felt unhappy after Wednesday fame
    • Ozzy Osbourne suffering 'badly' from ADHD
    • Jackie Chan blames 'too much money' for lukewarm reception of Rush Hour 3
    • 2nd woman tells jury Sean 'Diddy' Combs raped her
    • Jackie Chan wanted to 'give up' his acting dreams before seeing Karate Kid and Rocky
    • Ayumi Hamasaki, CL, Show Lo: Singapore concert calendar for 2025

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • Jurassic World, inflatable playgrounds and more: Family-friendly events and activities this June holiday
    • Kopitiam offering 60-cent hot kopi-o and teh-o from June to mark SG60
    • Porridge, pancakes and more: Popeyes enters Singapore's fast-food breakfast game
    • I visit GastroBeats again, here's whether it's still worth the hype
    • I had a mini cook-off with Chef Bob as he launches his latest creations - here's how it went
    • Hawkers say sales dropped after Chee Soon Juan wrongly shared their business closed
    • Uniqlo's local food tees draw buzz for looking 'eerily similar' to Singapore brand Musoka Club
    • Singapore ranked 2nd-most expensive city for an overseas education; only Asian city in top 20
    • I visit Swensen's Unlimited's new concept, and now I'm contemplating holding my wedding here
    • Special offers and wildlife experiences at Mandai attractions in celebration of SG60

Digicult

Digicult
    • World's best Dota 2 teams to compete for $1m prize pool in Singapore in November
    • A $500 wake-up call: How the Samsung Galaxy Ring made me realise my stress
    • Monster Hunter Wilds producer explains how game has remained unique and fresh over 20 years
    • Slim, sleek, but slightly too short-lived: Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge review
    • Initiative by IMDA, AI Verify Foundation tests AI accuracy, trustworthiness in real-world scenarios
    • Under siege? Helldivers 2's latest city to be invaded by aliens could be spoof of Singapore
    • Honor 400 Series launches in Singapore with first free in-device AI image-to-video tool
    • Home Team humanoid robots to be deployed by mid-2027, $100m to be invested: Josephine Teo
    • Ado concert review: Singer without a face ignites fans while in cage with only silhouette visible
    • EU and US authorities take down malware network

Money

Money
    • Wall Street equity indexes close higher after US-China tariff truce
    • Giant deal: Malaysian company to acquire Cold Storage and Giant supermarket chains in Singapore
    • Can you still own multiple properties in Singapore? Here's what you need to know in 2025
    • Selling your home for the first time? Here's a step-by-step timeline to follow in Singapore
    • Why some central 2-bedroom homeowners in Singapore are stuck
    • How the interest rate cycle works - and what it means for your home loan
    • Tampines, Sengkang and more towns set new 2-room all-time-high records - is this part of a broader trend?
    • More people rented in April 2025 despite higher prices, here's what drove it
    • Looking to buy Singapore property in 2025? Here's what's different (and what could catch you off guard)
    • 'Short-term, more conservative view': Local businesses struggle to come to terms with US tariffs

Latest

Latest
  • Trump administration orders enhanced vetting of all Harvard University-linked visa applicants
  • US Supreme Court lets Trump revoke humanitarian legal status for migrants
  • US CDC continues to recommend Covid-19 vaccines for children, contradicts Kennedy
  • Harvard's US-funded defence projects totaled $232 million in recent years, study shows
  • Conditions in Gaza are catastrophic despite renewed aid, UN says
  • Rock collapse at Indonesia quarry kills at least 10 people
  • Universities seek to lure US-bound students amid Trump crackdown
  • 2-year prison sentence for ex-Goldman banker Leissner in 1MDB case 'too short', Malaysia minister says
  • Trump envoy says Russian concern over Nato enlargement is fair

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • Woman crawls out of storm drain in shocking Manila street scene
  • DBS staff, police stop 2 victims from losing $820k to government official impersonation scams
  • 'Be humble in victory': PM Wong sends traditional 'Rules of Prudence' letter to PAP MPs after GE
  • Pedestrian, 84, dies in accident involving minibus in Choa Chu Kang
  • NDP 2025 marks SG60 with expanded celebrations from Padang to Marina Bay
  • Obesity rates are rising in Singapore, but is overeating the only cause?
  • Trump administration blocks Harvard from enrolling foreign students, threatens broader crackdown 
  • 'We apologise for the operational lapse': NUS responds to backlash over disposal of Yale-NUS books
  • No joke: Bangkok condo resident releases snakes in corridor to protest neighbour's noisy dog
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.