Award Banner
Award Banner

Sometimes, this time really is different

Sometimes, this time really is different

The four most dangerous words in investing are "This time it's different." But investing is challening because sometimes, this time really is different.

Sir John Templeton, one of the true investing greats, once said that the four most dangerous words in investing are "This time it's different." 

He wanted to warn us that if we ignore history, we're doing so at our own peril. As French writer Jean-Baptiste Alphonse Karr once stated, "the more things change, the more they stay the same". 

But what makes investing so challenging is that sometimes, this time really is different.  

WHEN DIVIDEND YIELDS CHANGE PERMANENTLY

There were two huge crashes in the US stock market in the early 20th century. One happened in 1929, during the infamous Great Depression, when US stocks fell by more than 80 per cent at the 1932 bottom. The other, which is less well-known, occurred in the first decade of the 1900s and was known as the Panic of 1907. 

Something interesting happened prior to both of these crises. In the first half of the 20th century, the dividend yield of US stocks were higher than the country's bond yield most of the time. The only two occasions when the dividend yield fell below the bond yield were - you guessed it - just before the Panic of 1907 and the Great Depression.

PHOTO: The Good Investors

Knowing what happened in the first half of the 1900s, it's easy for us to think that US stocks would crash the next time the dividend yield fell below the bond yield. So guess what happened when the dividend yield of US stocks started once again to slip behind the bond yield in the late 1950s?

PHOTO: The Good Investors

The bond yield ended up staying higher than the dividend yield all the way until it was late into the first decade of the 2000s!

PHOTO: The Good Investors

If we were investing in the US in the 1950s and wanted to invest based on the historical relationship between dividend and bond yields in the first-half of the 1900s, we had no chance at all to invest for decades. 

And yet from 1955 (before the dividend yield fell below the bond yield) to 2008 (when the dividend yield briefly became higher than the bond yield again), the S&P 500's price increased by nearly 2,400 per cent.

Read Also
money
Why I invest only in stocks

WHEN A SIGN OF CHEAPNESS STOPS WORKING 

Walter Schloss is one of my investing heroes, but he's not too well-known among the general public. That's a real pity because Schloss's track record is astounding.  

From 1956 to 2000, Schloss's investment firm produced an annualised return of 15.3 per cent, turning every $1,000 invested into more than $525,000. Over the same time frame, the US stock market, as a whole, had compounded at merely 11.5 per cent per year - $1,000 would have become just $120,000.

In 1985, Schloss was interviewed by the investing publication Barron's. During the interview, he recounted a story involving his one-time boss and fellow investing luminary, Benjamin Graham:

"Graham used to have this theory that if there were no working capital stocks around, that meant the market was too high…

… [That's] because historically, when there were no working capital stocks, the market collapsed. That worked pretty well till about 1960, when there weren't any working capital stocks, but the market kept going up. So that theory went out."

Schloss provided an explanation of what a working capital stock is in the same interview:

"Suppose a company's current assets are $10 million; the current liabilities are $3 million. There's $7 million in working capital. And, they are, say, $2 million in debt. Take that off. So there's $5 million of adjusted working capital. And say there are 100,000 shares, so they got $50 a share of working capital.

Now, if that stock were selling at 30 bucks a share, it would be kind of interesting."

To put it simply, working capital stocks are stocks that are priced very cheaply compared to the assets they own. Graham's theory was that if the market no longer has such cheap stocks, then a crash is imminent.

The model worked fine for a while, then it stopped working, as working capital stocks became scarce near-permanently from the 1960s onwards. In fact, Schloss had to change his investment strategy. During an interview with Outstanding Investors' Digest in the late 1980s, Schloss said (emphasis is mine):

Read Also
money
What you should know about Singapore's Straits Times Index

"Yes. I think it has - largely because of the situation in the market. Graham-Newman [Benjamin Graham's investment firm] used to buy working capital stocks - which I thought was a great idea.

But by 1960, there were practically no working capital stocks. With the exception of 1974, at the very bottom of that market, there have been practically no working capital stocks.

A good way of seeing it is to look at Value Line's [a business publication showing financial numbers of US stocks] list of working capital stocks. If you go back 15 years, you'll see they have some on the list. Today, there are very few. And the ones that are on the list are really pretty bad - often with a lot of debt - especially in relationship to the equity.

With working capital stocks gone, we look next at book value."

Schloss was right to have tweaked his strategy. The US stock market has been marching higher - much higher - since the disappearance of working capital stocks. From the start of 1960 to today, the S&P 500 has increased from 60 points to over 3,000. That's more than a 50-fold jump in value.

RECOGNISING WHEN THINGS ARE DIFFERENT

It's important for us to acknowledge that conditions in financial markets can change in permanent or near-permanent ways to severely blunt the usefulness of historical experience. 

The limits of using history can be applied to individual stocks too. For instance, it's tempting for us to conclude that a stock is a bargain if it has lower valuations now compared to its own history. But we should also carefully consider if there's anything that has permanently changed.

Bankruptcy risks. Industry obsolesce. Incompetent management. Absurdly high valuations in the past. These factors, and more, could render history useless as a guide for the future.

Many investors love to look at historical valuation data when studying the markets. I do too. But when doing so, it's crucial to remember that things can change. What has worked in the past may no longer be valid in the future. We need to recognise that sometimes, this time really is different. 

This article was first published in The Good Investors. All content is displayed for general information purposes only and does not constitute professional financial advice.

homepage

trending

trending
    Star Awards 2025 celebrates 30th anniversary with every All-Time Favourite Artiste reuniting on stage
    Some monkeys trapped in Punggol last year euthanised due to 'aggressive' behaviour: NParks
    Ex-Mediacorp actress Le Yao condemns Ian Fang: 'You want the benefits from the limelight but don't set strict standards for yourself?'
    Singaporean Amos Yee's parole from US jail delayed after he violated terms of release
    Beach Road slashing: Man pleads guilty to attempted murder of wife in 2022
    More than 3,000 new jobs in rail, bus sectors to be added to support expansion: Chee Hong Tat
    Poultry supply in Singapore not affected by bird flu outbreak in Brazil, supermarkets say
    'Only one chance at life': Chinese student, 18, misses exam to save classmate suffering heart attack
    Babymonster, Gigi Leung, Elva Hsiao and other stars spotted at Lady Gaga's Singapore concerts
    'Thankful for the neighbourliness': MP Cai Yinzhou on resident who alerted others to Toa Payoh flat fire
    Singapore's beef kway teow ranks 18th in best stir-fried dishes list, Indonesia's sambal goreng takes crown
    'Gaslighted the victim': Judge sentences actor Ian Fang to 40 months' jail for sex with 15-year-old

Singapore

Singapore
    • Tiong Bahru residents to vote on colour scheme over purple backlash; MP Foo Cexiang urges 'patience'
    • 2 Singaporeans found dead in KL homestay, ketamine found
    • 'Forever missed. Forever loved': Sister of Singaporean boy who died on Mount Kinalabu finishes climb on his behalf
    • 'No further action', says Ng Chee Meng after FB user Rich Sng's apology; Ong Ye Kung, Chee Hong Tat issue statement
    • Daily roundup: Poultry supply in Singapore not affected by bird flu outbreak in Brazil, supermarkets say — and other top stories today
    • Singaporean Malone Lam charged in US for orchestrating $340m crypto theft
    • Singaporean nabbed for allegedly committing indecent acts against boy at Japan hot spring
    • No need to stockpile pork, says FairPrice as Malaysian prices rise
    • WP's Andre Low and Eileen Chong declared elected NCMPs
    • Daily roundup: Don Don Donki brings back plastic bags — and other top stories today

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • 'Sorry for bad drawing': Yim Si-wan plays games with Singapore fans, shares South Korea travel tips
    • Gossip mill: Wife of veteran Hong Kong actor Ai Wai dies of liver disease, Kwon Yul announces wedding, Shinee's new single has same name as late Jonghyun's final album
    • 'His criticism has no effect on me': Quan Yi Fong responds to Addy Lee's accusations
    • K-pop idols IU, Enhypen's Jungwon and Seventeen join in on cat shadow trend
    • Conan O'Brien cast in Toy Story 5
    • Michael J. Fox's 'humour and courage' evident in his return to acting, says Harrison Ford
    • Wes Anderson mocks Donald Trump's movie tariffs plan
    • Jennifer Lawrence had 'great hormones' while she was filming Die, My Love
    • 'I will never stop': Tom Cruise intends to keep making movies into his 100s
    • Aubrey O'Day brands Sean 'Diddy' Combs 'selfish' for having his kids attend his sex trafficking trial

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • Back with a bang: Burgs ends 2-year hiatus with new standalone restaurant at Arab Street
    • 'You asked, we listened': Don Don Donki brings back plastic bags
    • Furry capabara EVs, self-driving mini bar, and more - here are the wackiest cars we saw at Auto Shanghai 2025
    • Heiress Kim Lim 'disappointed' after finding Chanel bag she sold for charity listed on Carousell
    • We check out Hiap Joo Bakery's new vending machine selling its famous banana cake
    • We head to China to check out how Singapore's top-selling car brand intends to transform the automotive industry
    • 7 toilet door ideas for all types of spaces
    • Things to do in Nagoya, Japan: A cultural guide to arts, music and markets
    • Inside Balmoral Park: Rare freehold landed homes with 1.6 plot ratio in District 10
    • Why we chose a walk-up apartment (yes, with no lift) for our first home

Digicult

Digicult
    • World's best Dota 2 teams to compete for $1m prize pool in Singapore in November
    • A $500 wake-up call: How the Samsung Galaxy Ring made me realise my stress
    • Monster Hunter Wilds producer explains how game has remained unique and fresh over 20 years
    • Google Pixel 9a: The best AI-centric phone under $800 in 2025?
    • Western intelligence agencies warn spyware threat targeting Taiwan, Tibetan rights advocates
    • Taiwan says China using generative AI to ramp up disinformation and 'divide' the island
    • Russian court fines Telegram app for refusal to remove anti-government content, TASS reports
    • One Beijing man's quest to keep cooking — and connecting with Americans — on camera
    • Nintendo Switch 2 to launch in June with US$449.99 price tag
    • Games in April: RPGs, racing and Ronaldo in a fighting game

Money

Money
    • Wall Street equity indexes close higher after US-China tariff truce
    • Giant deal: Malaysian company to acquire Cold Storage and Giant supermarket chains in Singapore
    • Selling your condo? This overlooked factor could quietly undercut your selling price
    • Using a personal loan for a used car purchase: What you need to know
    • 6 prime HDB shophouses for sale at $73m in Singapore: A look inside the rare portfolio
    • Croatia's Game of Thrones filming sites face threat from Trump tariffs
    • A new high in Choa Chu Kang: $690k for a 4-room flat
    • SIA rewards staff with over 7 months' bonus after record $2.8b full-year profit
    • Apec warns of tariff impact on trade as members seek deals with US
    • Family of Koufu Group founders to buy Caldecott Hill GCB site for $58m

Latest

Latest
  • Malnutrition in Gaza could rise exponentially, UNRWA official says
  • Israeli strikes kill dozens in Gaza as criticism of Israel grows
  • Offer to gift Trump an aircraft is 'normal thing' between allies, Qatar's PM says
  • Iran's Supreme Leader Khamenei doubts success of nuclear talks with US
  • Gaza ceasefire talks in Doha have not led anywhere due to sides' deep differences, says Qatar PM
  • Israel's easing of humanitarian aid access to Gaza insufficient, French foreign minister
  • At least 58 corpses found in Libyan hospital, ministry says
  • New Zealand defers vote on rare suspension of Indigenous lawmakers
  • Australia's opposition coalition splits after election loss

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • Baby suspected to have been eaten by monitor lizard in Thailand, only head found
  • 'Dog will return soon': GE2025 independent candidate Jeremy Tan wants to contest again
  • Ong Ye Kung leads PAP team to victory while elder brother Howard Ong loses in Australia's election on the same day
  • Tan Kiat How weighs in on viral video of Gan Kim Yong being ignored by passers-by in Punggol
  • PSP's Tan Cheng Bock turns 85; SDP's Paul Tambyah joins celebration at Teban Gardens
  • PM Wong urges voters to 'choose leaders of good character' in PAP's first party political broadcast
  • It is 'important for Singapore's democracy' that WP wins more seats, says Pritam in election broadcast
  • GE2025: PSP, RDU, SDP, PPP, PAR, NSP promise to push for policy changes if elected to Parliament in first political broadcast
  • 'Everyone has the right to express their feelings': WP candidates address four-cornered fight in Tampines GRC
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.