KTPH issues clarification following online allegations by daughter of man who died during ICU stay


PUBLISHED ONBYSean Ler"Our healthcare workers did their very best in caring for the patient," said Khoo Teck Puat Hospital (KTPH) in a statement posted on its Facebook on Friday (Nov 20) night, as it set out clarifications to claims regarding the care of a late patient under its care.
The claims, posted on the social media account of the late patient's daughter, centred around the family's experience and concerns regarding his care.
In her post, the woman, surnamed Toh, said she was speaking up because she felt that no other family should ever have to experience the devastating loss of a family member while being left with many unanswered questions about their care.
According to Toh, her 52-year-old father was admitted on Sept 24 after suffering a persistent high fever for eight days. She said the family had hoped that he would receive the necessary investigations, antibiotics and medical treatment needed to recover.
"However, we were informed that antibiotics could not be administered immediately because he was an alcoholic and still had alcohol in his system," she wrote, adding that they were told antibiotics could only be started after the alcohol had been withdrawn from his system.
On this allegation, the hospital said its review found that the medical team had administered antibiotics to the man on the same day he was admitted.
A key concern raised by Toh was a 45-minute period between 1.30am and 2.15am on Sept 27.
According to the woman, they received a call from KTPH at 3am that her father had suffered a cardiac arrest and was already in the Intensive Care Unit (ICU).
She alleged that the hospital was unable to account for how long her father's heart had stopped.
"We were told that he could have been without a heartbeat for anywhere between one minute and 45 minutes. How is this an acceptable explanation from a hospital entrusted with someone’s life?"
Toh also raised questions on whether "appropriate monitoring and timely intervention" had been applied.
In response, KTPH stated that CCTV footage showed there was no "45-minute lapse" as alleged in Toh's post.
Detailing what happened, the hospital pointed out that the patient was assisted to the toilet at 1.40am and was brought back to his bed to rest at 1.56am.
A staff later entered the man's cubicle again at 2.15am, found him unresponsive and a medical team was activated to commence resuscitation efforts.
He was then transferred to the ICU.
Toh also said that amid their devastation, "certain remarks" from the medical team made the situation even more unbearable.
For example, the woman said a doctor told them that even if her father woke up, he would likely remain in a vegetative state and that "it would be better if he did not wake up".
She also alleged that they were told within just three to four days that the man was unlikely to regain consciousness, even while he was showing some ability to breathe on his own.
They were also purportedly told to make a decision on the removal of a ventilator, which they agreed to on Oct 4.
"What I cannot accept is that my father walked into Khoo Teck Puat Hospital seeking treatment for a fever, but never returned home," Toh added.
The hospital said the ICU care team provided regular verbal updates to the family and also held a family conference to offer support and address their queries.
It added that during these discussions, the ICU team explained the patient's prognosis and seriousness of his brain injury, including the quality of life and available care options.
KTPH also found that the medical information and care options conveyed by its ICU doctor were "clinically appropriate for the patient's condition and prognosis".
Nonetheless the hospital said it regrets and apologises if the remarks had come across as insensitive during that difficult period.
Ending off its clarification, KTPH reiterated that there was no lapse in care rendered to the patient.
"Our healthcare workers did their very best in caring for the patient.
"Our care team engaged the daughter and her family verbally and in a family conference to explain the patient’s care plan and available options."
It added that Toh and her family did not raise issues that were unresolved during those conversations, until her social media post on Nov 17.
According to KTPH, it had tried over the past three days to contact Toh via phone calls and text messages to invite her for a family conference to address the concerns.
"We hope that the daughter can get in touch with us as soon as possible so that we can explain our findings and address any outstanding questions she may have. We remain committed to engaging her," it said.
[[nid:724264]]