Protecting 30% of the planet to save nature is not as simple as it sounds

Protecting 30% of the planet to save nature is not as simple as it sounds
A lake in a shape of a heart is seen surrounded by autumn-coloured trees outside Balashikha, Moscow region, Russia, on Oct 4, 2021.
PHOTO: Reuters

AsiaOne has launched EarthOne, a new section dedicated to environmental issues — because we love the planet and we believe science. Find articles like this there.


MONTREAL - From the lush Amazon rainforest to the frigid Arctic Ocean, the world’s landscapes – and all the wildlife they contain – are under threat, and the world needs to set aside a third of all land and sea territories to save them, United Nations experts say.

The call is central to the global agreement being hashed out this month at the UN biodiversity summit in Montreal. If approved at the end of the summit next week, governments would be agreeing to set aside 30 per cent of their land and sea territories for conservation by 2030 – doubling the amount of land area and more than tripling the ocean territory currently under conservation.

More than 110 countries have come out in support of the 30-by-30 goal, including Canada, the United States and France.

Proponents argue that the goal is crucial to reversing the destruction of nature. Currently, more than 1 million species are at risk of extinction, while the global insect population declines at up to 2 per cent every year and about 40 per cent of the world’s remaining plant species are in trouble.

But as is often the case with science-based policy, the details matter to whether a 30 per cent global conservation goal can truly save the world’s imperiled species and places.

“The danger, as with all these sorts of events populated by politicians, is they want a simple number,” said Stuart Pimm, a biologist at Duke University. “They would like to be able to leave Montreal and say we’re going to protect 30 per cent of the planet. But that alone is not enough.”

Is 30% sufficient?

This driving question ultimately comes down to quantity versus quality.

There is not a strong scientific argument behind 30 per cent as the threshold for staving off species loss, experts said. In reality, it could take a much greater percentage of land or sea – or a lower percentage – depending which areas are selected.

“Thirty per cent is neither necessary nor sufficient,” Pimm said. “If we do things the right way, we protect most biodiversity by being smart – by protecting the areas that matter.”

Read Also
Nature needs $520 billion annually by 2025, UN says
world
Nature needs $520 billion annually by 2025, UN says

There is a temptation, he said, to conserve vast tracts of land that are already without many people, but also have relatively little biodiversity, such as the Arctic tundra or Saharan desert.

But it is important to protect areas with lots of different species, known as biodiversity hot spots, even if they are more challenging to conserve because people live there or there are extractive industries.

Protecting narrow slices of land and sea such as Australia’s Great Barrier Reef or the Andes mountains, can offer far more reward than protecting large swathes of prairie, for example.

“A numerical target isn’t going to work,” Pimm said. “If we were to just protect 50 per cent of the planet, and we protect the least populated 50 per cent, it will do very little for biodiversity.”

A June 2022 study in the journal Science found that at least 44 per cent of global land area would be needed to protect areas with a high diversity of species, prevent the loss of intact ecosystems, and optimise the representation of different landscapes and species. But more than 1.8 billion people live in these areas.

However, co-author Hugh Possingham, a researcher at the University of Queensland, noted that “while there is nothing magical about 30 per cent… targets help focus the attention of nations.”

“I see 30 per cent as a goal that most countries can reasonably achieve by 2030,” he said, adding some countries, such as Bhutan, had already passed this goal.

A national or international target

One of the key tension points that has emerged in the 30-by-30 debate at COP15 is whether the target should be carried out globally or at a national level.

It is an important distinction, scientists and negotiators said. Some countries are small, without much land to set aside for nature. Others are vast and still contain a high degree of biodiversity, such as tropical forest nations like Brazil and Indonesia. Were such countries to protect only 30 per cent of their territories, that could actually result in a significant loss of nature.

“Some ecosystems are more diverse and more fragile,” Possingham said. “Places like the Amazon need much greater fractions than 30 per cent to conserve their biodiversity – and maintain ecosystem functions that stabilize the planet’s climate.”

Currently, just under 50 per cent of the Amazon is under some form of official protection or indigenous stewardship, so a national pledge to conserve 30 per cent would represent a significant downgrade.

What counts as protected?

The other dispute plaguing 30-by-30 is over what should count as protection. Some countries might allow people to live within protected areas or promote indigenous stewardship of these lands. Some might even allow for extractive industries to operate under permits and regulation. In other cases, conservation areas are off limits to everyone.

The European Union has proposed allowing activities like logging, mining and fishing to be carried out under conservation management for 20 per cent of protected areas, while 10 per cent would be held under stricter protections.

The idea caused environmental nonprofit Greenpeace to accuse the EU last week of trying to water down language on 30-by-30, which the EU denied.

“Whatever activity is eventually happening in those areas, it should not harm biodiversity and the functioning of the ecosystem,” said Ladislav Miko, a special biodiversity envoy from the Czech Republic with the European Commission, at a news conference last week.

Source: Reuters

homepage

trending

trending
    'Our role is to make ourselves obsolete': First-time WP candidates reflect on GE2025 and whether they'll run again
    E-Junkies: Members of new K-pop girl group Kiiras put teen life on hold for idol career
    Senior Malaysian army officers who allegedly masterminded smuggling syndicate busted
    Mariah Carey, Treasure, Eric Moo: Singapore concert calendar for 2025
    Scoot launching new flights to Japan, including Okinawa, and Thailand from December; tickets from $128
    Jimmy Kimmel has obtained Italian citizenship
    Shoelace to tie umbilical cord: Woman in Malaysia goes into labour by roadside, passing motorists help deliver baby
    Jail for woman who forged medical documents in bid to quickly withdraw her CPF funds
    New Hawkers' Street outlet at Tangs Plaza features 6 Michelin-recognised brands, opens on Aug 18
    Jacelyn Tay gifts her Star Awards trophies to long-time fan
    Malaysia's top court dismisses appeal against jailed ex-PM Najib's house arrest bid
    'I would be crying every day during lunch': Rebecca Lim recalls feeling inadequate in 1st acting role after childbirth

Singapore

Singapore
    • Singapore upgrades 2025 growth forecast but warns that outlook remains 'clouded by uncertainty'
    • 2 Singapore drivers allegedly detained in Legoland for offering illegal ride-hailing services; cars seized
    • Singapore delivers ninth tranche of humanitarian aid to Gaza
    • 'Proof of love between 2 nations': Malaysian man creates SG60 shirt to thank Singaporeans who helped him through hard times
    • Off-duty SCDF officer killed in Punggol crash; 15-year-old taken to hospital
    • 'We have to be ready anywhere, anytime': Off-duty healthcare professionals from Singapore revive elderly man in JB
    • Johor govt seeking stricter laws against foreign drivers misusing subsidised fuel
    • Service on North East Line resumes
    • Singaporean woman deported from Malaysia
    • PM Wong to deliver National Day Rally speech on Aug 17

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • Huang Zitao and Xu Yiyang to hold wedding in October with 100 fans in attendance
    • Zheng Geping awarded Public Service Medal for contributions to Woodlands CCC
    • Blackpink's Jisoo releases Your Love special video filmed at Rainforest Wild Asia in Mandai
    • 'My sweat seeped through the seams': Zhang Zetong on 'suffering' and working with new virtual technology for drama Perfectly Imperfect
    • Taylor Swift announces new album called The Life of a Showgirl
    • Noah Centineo to star in Rambo origins movie
    • Maluma stops concert to reprimand fan who brought along a baby
    • 'I felt I would die if I closed my eyes': Ada Choi's husband Max Zhang recalls suffering heart attack in April
    • Tom Holland admits putting on his Spider-Man suit 'feels different this time'
    • Jet Li's eldest daughter getting married

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • Ong Ye Kung rebuts KF Seetoh's claims regarding treatment of stallholders at Bukit Canberra Hawker Centre
    • Popular Japanese restaurant Shaburi & Kintan Buffet to shutter after 9 years
    • Singapore ranks top in Asia for work-life balance and 25th in the world, according to Remote study
    • Embracing Singlish as part of our identity: Paiseh for what?
    • BYD Atto 2 electric compact SUV launched in Singapore
    • I've lived in Twin Vew for 4 years: What's it like living without an MRT station nearby
    • Even cheaper than Bali: 5 hidden Asian islands you (and your wallet) will love
    • 4 condo layouts and features buyers are moving away from in 2025
    • How to get your driving licence in Singapore - fast
    • 'Last' meals: How durian, chilli crab, and KFC bring comfort to the dying in Singapore

Digicult

Digicult
    • Slim, sleek, but slightly too short-lived: Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge review
    • World's best Dota 2 teams to compete for $1m prize pool in Singapore in November
    • Apple Maps brings 3D landmarks and road-level realism to Singapore
    • The best AI tutor for O-level subjects: ChatGPT, Gemini or The Wise Otter?
    • Vivo X Fold5: A foldable contender with a few class-leading surprises
    • Here's everything in GPT-5 that's new and different than OpenAI's previous AI models
    • Australia regulator says YouTube, others 'turning a blind eye' to child abuse material
    • ZipZap car subscription service launches in Singapore
    • Sony RX1R III brings back the compact full-frame but not the Sony playbook
    • China's Premier Li proposes global AI co-operation organisation

Money

Money
    • Up 4.3%: Singapore's economy grew in Q2 despite US tariff fears
    • Goh Cheng Liang, Nippon Paint billionaire and richest Singaporean, dies aged 98
    • StarHub buys rest of MyRepublic's broadband business in $105m deal; comes after Simba buys M1
    • Keppel to sell M1 unit's telco business to Simba for $1.43b
    • Singapore can deliver and thrive in a fragmented global economy: Morgan Stanley analysts
    • Over 70% of Ang Mo Kio's 4-room million-dollar resales in the past 3 years came from this project
    • DBS beats expectations with $2.82b net profit for second quarter, maintains 2025 outlook
    • Carro targets US IPO with over $3.8b valuation, sources say
    • US companies spending record amounts to protect executives as threats rise
    • Electric car-sharing firm BlueSG to wind down current operations on Aug 8

Latest

Latest
  • Daily roundup: Ex-NMP Calvin Cheng resolves differences with ex-SDP chairman over Gaza comments — and other top stories today
  • Russia has won war in Ukraine, Hungary's Orban says
  • South Korean President Lee to visit Japan for summit with PM Ishiba, Seoul says
  • Thai student, 17, kicks, rains blows on female teacher for not giving him full marks in exam
  • China's military says it 'drove away' US destroyer near Scarborough Shoal
  • New Zealand PM Luxon says Israel's Netanyahu has 'lost the plot'
  • Zelenskiy, European leaders to speak to Trump ahead of Putin summit
  • 'Cooked alive': Europe's wildfires hit tourism spots and forests
  • Mothers of Gaza hostages fear Israeli offensive will endanger their sons

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • Young Malaysian couple's first trip ends in tragedy after motorbike crashes on bend in Cameron Highlands
  • Man remanded after wielding knife, trying to snatch baby in Penang supermarket
  • Malaysia's border control agency gives ICA cake to mark SG60
  • Tourist in Hong Kong killed after cabby, 80, crashes into pillar outside hotel
  • 2 Malaysian men nabbed at Woodlands Checkpoint for allegedly smuggling drugs worth over $150k into Singapore
  • Parents reject $30k settlement from kindergarten in JB after son suffocates to death in school van
  • Pritam gets candid with kids’ questions on his worst subjects and favourite song in radio interview
  • Bro-code before go-mode: Meet the duo leading NDP 2025
  • LTA, Singapore bus operators reviewing Malaysia’s request to start services from JB at 4am
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.