Award Banner
Award Banner

Judge dismisses ex-MP's claim his son bought Balestier shophouse as a gift for him

Judge dismisses ex-MP's claim his son bought Balestier shophouse as a gift for him
The conservation shophouse in Martaban Road was bought in December 2009 for $2.1 million and registered in Dr Chiang Hai Ding's name.
PHOTO: The Straits Times

SINGAPORE – A High Court judge rejected the contention of former MP and retired ambassador Chiang Hai Ding that he was the sole owner of a Balestier shophouse that his son’s former wife has claimed is a matrimonial asset.

The conservation shophouse in Martaban Road was bought in December 2009 for $2.1 million and registered in Dr Chiang’s name.

He put down $300,000 towards the down payment, while his son Joon Arn paid $520,000 and took out a $1.28 million mortgage.

At the time, rules stipulating that the borrower must also be the mortgagor had not yet come about.

Ms Sabrina Tan, who married Mr Chiang Joon Arn in December 2011 and filed for divorce in October 2020, had sued father and son in the High Court over the ownership of the shophouse.

The suit arose out of disagreement in ongoing divorce proceedings over whether the shophouse – now estimated to be worth between $3 million and $4 million – falls within the pool of matrimonial assets to be divided.

In a written judgment on Thursday, Justice Hoo Sheau Peng said she had no hesitation in dismissing the Chiangs’ narrative that Joon Arn had bought the property as a gift to his father because he wanted to help the older man realise his dream of living in a shophouse.

However, the judge also found insufficient evidence to support Ms Tan’s main contention that Dr Chiang was holding the property on trust for the couple.

Ms Tan, who was represented by Ms Melanie Ho, Mr Gavin Neo and Ms Jolyn Khoo, said the property was bought in Dr Chiang’s name because the couple could not buy private property in their own names.

This was due to the five-year minimum occupation period (MOP) after their purchase of a Housing Board flat at Pinnacle@Duxton.

Justice Hoo ruled that, given the financial contributions towards the purchase price, Dr Chiang was the beneficial owner of 14.29 per cent of the shophouse and was holding the other 85.71 per cent on trust for his son.

Whether Mr Chiang’s 85.71 per cent stake in the shophouse forms part of the pool of matrimonial assets to be divided will be separately determined in the divorce proceedings.

Justice Hoo concluded from the evidence that, in happier times, the couple desired to own a shophouse and Dr Chiang helped by allowing the property to be registered in his name.

Former MP Chiang Hai Ding and his son Joon Arn (both left) are being sued by his son's former wife Sabrina Tan (right). PHOTO: The Straits Times

Given that she was about to marry Mr Chiang, Ms Tan did not object to the arrangement, the judge surmised. In fact, Ms Tan was involved in the acquisition of the property and in taking care of the property after its purchase.

As it transpired, Mr Chiang was short of funds, and Dr Chiang contributed towards the down payment.

“While this gained Dr Chiang a small beneficial interest in the property, it was not meant to be an outright gift to him,” said the judge.

Dr Chiang was the People’s Action Party MP for Ulu Pandan from 1970 to 1984; he also served as Singapore’s ambassador to more than 10 countries, including the former Soviet Union.

Ms Tan worked as a chartered accountant. In 2002, she gave up her career and moved to the United States to live with Mr Chiang, also a chartered accountant, who was posted there for work.

The couple successfully balloted for the Pinnacle flat in 2004 or 2005 as their matrimonial home.

In 2009, Ms Tan identified the shophouse as a suitable property to buy. The shophouse was rented out and the rental income used to repay the mortgage. At times when the property was not rented out, Mr Chiang would service the mortgage.

He paid the property tax for at least the past six years, and reimbursed his father for income tax payments arising from the property’s rental income.

In her judgment, Justice Hoo said the assertion that Dr Chiang dreamed of living in a shophouse was not supported by any evidence. Instead, he testified that he had never stayed there and had no intention of doing so.

The judge said it was very unlikely that Mr Chiang, who was just starting out in his career and preparing to settle down with Ms Tan in 2009, would make such a substantial gift to his wealthy father.

She said Dr Chiang’s explanation that he had to contribute to the cost of his own gift because his son had underestimated the down payment required, was “unconvincing”.

Although she rejected the gift narrative, the judge said the deficiencies in the defendants’ case could not be used to fill up gaps in Ms Tan’s case that the parties had intended for Dr Chiang to hold the shophouse on the couple’s behalf.

The judge noted that in 2014, before the couple’s relationship soured, Dr Chiang willed the shophouse only to Mr Chiang.

She found that Mr Chiang’s financial contributions towards the property were his own, and not made on the couple’s behalf. She noted that for the Pinnacle flat, which was their matrimonial home, Ms Tan had made direct financial contributions of her own.

ALSO READ: Couple flips Kitchener Road property for $3.7m profit in just 5 months

This article was first published in The Straits Times. Permission required for reproduction.

homepage

trending

trending
    140 coffeeshops in Singapore offering SG60 promotions and discounts, here's what to expect
    Man, 63, drove through a playground and into a swimming pool after drinking alcohol
    Islamic association says former NMP Calvin Cheng's comments on pro-Palestine activists 'dehumanising, dismissive'
    'I felt lonely and upset': Grandma, 73, worked at hawker stall to support grandkids during daughter's imprisonment
    Govt's response to US tariffs 'partly to instil fear': PSP chairman Tan Cheng Bock
    Thrill or chill: Enjoy more for less at Resorts World Genting
    47 injured in Tokyo expressway bus accident; at least 1 Singaporean on board
    SCDF team recovers body from partially collapsed hotel after Myanmar quake, sets up 2 medical outposts
    Man charged for allegedly stealing over $1,800 worth of items at Changi Airport in 3 hours
    New platform for a new era: Audi A5 Sedan now available in Singapore
    Woman who allegedly cheated son in Netflix's Con Mum charged in Singapore with fraud
    Edwin Goh proposes to Rachel Wan, both returning to Singapore after 2 years in Australia

Singapore

Singapore
    • 'I thought I could outwit scammers': Woman who lost over $78,000 to job scam in 4 days
    • 'Akan datang': WP Sengkang MPs coy on whether they will remain as team in GE2025
    • Woman hit by car at Sengkang East Drive pedestrian crossing after cars refuse to give way
    • Former MOF director Shawn Loh seen at Jalan Besar GRC community events
    • Salt, sauces and instant noodles to have Nutri-Grade labels by mid-2027
    • Singaporeans have to work together to deal with uncertainty, says SM Lee, citing new Trump tariffs
    • Fewer candidates this time, but PSP confirms it is contesting West Coast-Jurong West and Chua Chu Kang GRCs
    • SG60 initiative timing not planned to coincide with GE, says Tan See Leng
    • Man, 55, found dead in car left stationary for 2 days in Paya Lebar
    • PSP's potential new candidates seen at walkabout in Boon Lay

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • NewJeans changes social media handles and deletes posts after court ruling
    • Hong Kong actor Lee Lung Kei still plans to marry fiancee 37 years younger after her release from prison
    • 'My brain got so fried up': Gurmit Singh hit by anxiety attack while acting in his 1st Chinese drama
    • Gossip mill: Diana Ser's son to enlist, Takeshi Kaneshiro back after 3 years, agency says late Sulli wasn't forced to film nude scene
    • Paul Sculfor says his kids gave him 'purpose' after battling addiction issues
    • Ed Sheeran releases new single Azizam
    • UK police charge comedian Russell Brand with rape, sexual assaults
    • Jean-Claude Van Damme accused of having sex with trafficked women
    • 'I was right there just 3cm behind her': Exo's Kai recalls joys of simple life during military service, meeting commuter checking him out online
    • Jim Carrey pays tribute to Val Kilmer's 'grace and courage'

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • The rise of Chinese F&B brands in Singapore: What stirs Singaporeans' appetites?
    • AI and art: Studio Ghibli-inspired trend sparks debate on ethics and consent
    • The iconic Milo Van beverage is now available in supermarkets
    • Disney's Beauty and the Beast musical to make Asia premiere in Singapore this December
    • A bright minimalist condo apartment with a loft
    • The truth about integrated developments in Singapore: 5 homeowners share their living experience
    • How to pay in China like a local: 2025 guide for foreigners and tourists
    • Battlebox, but make it art: Portals will change how you see this underground bunker
    • 5 things I didn't expect to find in my new BTO estate
    • Sunda Festival 2025: 2 friends shaping Singapore's music and festival scene

Digicult

Digicult
    • A $500 wake-up call: How the Samsung Galaxy Ring made me realise my stress
    • Monster Hunter Wilds producer explains how game has remained unique and fresh over 20 years
    • One Beijing man's quest to keep cooking — and connecting with Americans — on camera
    • Nintendo Switch 2 to launch in June with US$449.99 price tag
    • Games in April: RPGs, racing and Ronaldo in a fighting game
    • Is it time to get a MacBook at a good price? The M4 MacBook Air says yes
    • China's Baidu launches 2 new AI models as industry competition heats up
    • China's top universities expand enrolment to beef up capabilities in AI, strategic areas
    • International Women's Day: Meet the Singapore women levelling up in gaming
    • US indicts slew of alleged Chinese hackers, sanctions company over spy campaign

Money

Money
    • Giant deal: Malaysian company to acquire Cold Storage and Giant supermarket chains in Singapore
    • US stock futures tumble indicating another plummet on Wall Street
    • Trump compares tariffs to 'medicine' as markets point to rough week ahead
    • Personal loans for new parents: When do they make sense?
    • 9 best personal loans in Singapore with lowest interest rates (April 2025)
    • Best travel insurance policies for places prone to natural disasters (2025)
    • 'We spent just $5,000 on reno': Why some buyers are skipping big renovations in 2025
    • Wedding loan vs. personal loan: What's the best way to finance a wedding in Singapore
    • Triple record-breaking $3.06m EC: How did they manage it?
    • US starts collecting Trump's new 10% tariff, smashing global trade norms

Latest

Latest
  • Daily roundup: Man charged for allegedly stealing over $1,800 worth of items at Changi Airport in 3 hours — and other top stories today
  • China calls US tariffs 'bullying', urged others to continue with consultation
  • China holds military drills at newly expanded Cambodian naval base
  • North Korea holds first Pyongyang marathon after pandemic
  • Iran-backed militias in Iraq ready to disarm to avert Trump wrath
  • Australia's opposition dumps policy on return to office as election nears
  • Taiwan eyes zero tariffs with US, pledges more investment
  • Pope Francis makes surprise first appearance at Vatican after hospital stay
  • Anti-Trump protesters gather in Washington, other US cities

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • 'She should be with her family': Employer gives maid plane ticket, $800 to return to Myanmar and search for missing mum
  • 'He needed something to help him fight,' says man who bought Hokkien mee for dying patient
  • Thai woman struggles to evacuate during earthquake while her dog sleeps unfazed
  • Workers painting exterior of Geylang block discover man's skeletal remains in flat
  • 'New, younger' PAP team vows to reclaim WP-controlled Sengkang GRC, says Lam Pin Min
  • New face Jackson Lam 'very good on the ground' and will be asset to Parliament, says Shanmugam
  • Woman who publicised tips on how she evaded GST for luxury purchases fined $18k
  • Powerful quake in Southeast Asia kills several, 81 trapped in Bangkok building rubble
  • Dog dies after being skinned alive in Malaysia, animal welfare group condemns 'barbaric' act
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.