Choosing between an HDB flat and a condominium: The deciding factors

Choosing between an HDB flat and a condominium: The deciding factors
PHOTO: The Straits Times file

Singapore is one of the most expensive countries in the world to buy a property, but it also has a high ownership percentage of more than 90 per cent. Are Singaporeans rich?

That might be the initial assumption — given that public housing apartments, known as HDBs, has hit the S$1 million mark in recent years.

In fact, the high percentage of home-ownership can be attributed to the brilliant retirement-saving system called the CPF which helps many Singaporeans to become home-owners, as well as the generous amounts of grants the government provides.

Home-ownership is a common aspiration for many Singaporeans. However, there is always the dilemma between buying a HDB and a private property.

Considerations include lifestyle choice, eligibility and of course, the potential for capital appreciation should one hope to sell that property one day.

Here, we've listed some of the key considerations you may want to think about when making that expensive choice:

What's the purpose of buying a property?

The answer to this question may seem obvious to some but you may be surprised that many new home-buyers would answer, "both for staying and investment".

The fact is that you can't do both. Why? This is simply because the strategy undertaken to manage that property will be different depending on the objective, thus affecting the choice of property as well.

HDB flats are made for owner-occupancy because it is a type of public housing and as such, possess certain characteristics that make it more complicated for investment.

This includes meeting the eligibility schemes set out by the government for buyers, as well as a minimum occupation period before you can rent or sell.

You can obviously buy a private condominium for your own staying as well, but the type and location of your home can be affected by the objective for buying.

The Tanjong Rhu enclave. PHOTO: The Straits Times file

For instance, if you are buying it for your own staying, you will typically take into consideration the lifestyle needs of your family — you'd need adequate space to accommodate everyone, you might be looking for a place with several schools around, somewhere that you can have access to town centres and preferably a little out of the city as that you can have a quieter and more peaceful surrounding.

Compare this to buying a property for rental income.

You would probably go for a smaller studio or one bedroom unit nearer to the city centre, a location within walking distance to the MRT station and choose one that has certain sets of facilities that may appeal to the expat — BBQ pits, a gym and a swimming pool.

You'd also probably choose a newer condominium so that you do not need to spend on renovations.

Legal and financial eligibility

After determining a clear objective for buying a property, your eligibility to acquire the property plays an important part as well.

For HDBs, you will need to fulfil the nationality as well as family nucleus eligibility in order to qualify for purchase.

For condominiums, you do not have such restrictions, but foreigners will need to be aware of the additional buyer's stamp duty implemented as part of the property cooling measures introduced in 2013.

Singapore Permanent Resident would have to pay an extra five per cent on their first property purchase, and foreigners will need to top-up an additional 15 per cent.

Another important consideration involves another restriction set out as part of the cooling measures — Total Debt Servicing Ratio (TDSR). This applies to both Singaporeans and foreigners alike.

Basically, the TDSR limits the amount borrowers can spend on total debt repayments to 60 per cent of their gross monthly income.

Total debt repayments do not mean just your mortgage loan, but include other debts you may have, such as auto loans, study loans, personal loans and credit card debts.

So before you even start searching for your ideal home, it might be wise to work out the amount of loan you can take on based on your salary to narrow the choice of the type of properties you can afford.

What should you consider if you are buying a property for investment?

If you are set on buying a property for investment purpose, you'd need to take some calculated risk and consider the great macroeconomic environment.

Most people expect their rental income to help them cover the monthly mortgage repayments they'd need to pay. To do this, you may want to look at the general trend of the interest rate environment.

While we've got low interest rates for the last few years, many expect rates to start rising from 2016 onwards. If that's the case, you may want to secure a fixed-rate loan, or to include some buffer when you calculate the rental amount.

The rental price is also largely set by the demand and supply of rental flats. While your apartment may be able to command a premium due to its location, furnishings or facilities, you will not be able to escape the general trend.

Read Also
money
How to avoid ABSD when buying a second property: Understanding decoupling and how 99-1 works

As of the current situation, analysts are looking at a supply glut starting in 2016, and the downtrend in the property market isn't helping either.

In fact, the rental prices for suburban condominiums are actually falling closer to HDB rental price levels. Thus, you may want to study the macroeconomic environment before you take that plunge.

If you are more focused on capital gains, condominiums are perhaps the way to go since they cater to a wider range of buyers and historical data have shown that gains made in private housing are usually larger compared to public housing.

Having said that, there are always outliers, such as those who have bought at the peak between 2011-2013 and have since suffered huge losses.

As with all other types of investment, research and work out the numbers before signing on the dotted lines!

ALSO READ: Are we in a property buyer's or seller's market?

This article was first published in ValueChampion.

homepage

trending

trending
    Italian man allegedly tricked Singaporean woman into sex work in Dubai, on trial for human trafficking
    ICA foils attempts to smuggle over 850 vape products via checkpoints in last 5 days
    6 injured in chain collision between 5 trucks and lorries on TPE
    10.4ha of forest in Woodlands to be cleared from 2026 for industrial, mixed-use developments
    Malaysian PM Anwar orders probe into fighter jet crash at Kuantan airport
    'This is all for my child's future': Why an SIA flight attendant left the skies for a hawker stall
    Thai actress Orm Kornnaphat cries as chaos ensues at China fansign, organiser slammed for allegedly overselling benefits
    3 taken to hospitals, 50 evacuated following Toa Payoh fire
    Jail for man who committed incest with older daughter, took videos of younger child showering
    Woman in China buys lottery while taking shelter from rain, wins over $170k
    Bangkok's Michelin-starred Jay Fai fined after YouTuber's complaint about overcharging for dish
    Woman seeking man who helped to save 4-year-old son from drowning in hotel pool

Singapore

Singapore
    • Woman trapped between train doors: Judge rules SBS Transit '100% responsible'
    • 'I saw the driver waving': SMRT bus captain who fought car fire near KKH says he couldn't ignore call for help
    • $218 release fee: Car park operator at Woodlands VEP centre criticised for clamping cars parked illegally
    • Nearly 80% of visitors to Johor in 2025 were from Singapore, says Malaysian official
    • 'They're just like my own': This couple shares why they decided to foster a child with special needs
    • Alert from courier firm helps HSA uncover drugs, e-vaporisers with etomidate in raids
    • Who's sitting where: Singapore Parliament releases seating arrangements
    • More Singaporeans find religion has 'considerable influence' in their lives: IPS study
    • MOE reveals timeline of Sengkang Green Primary bullying saga; pupil who sent death threats caned for subsequent incident
    • 12th world record for Singaporean powerlifter Farhanna Farid at World Games

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • 'Dreams don't expire': Desmond Tan buys first landed home, marks 39th birthday
    • 'I almost became a widow': Ada Choi discusses husband suffering heart attack in Singapore
    • Jack Neo uses AI to create SG60 song and music video that includes Lee Kuan Yew
    • Health alert: Jet Li undergoes surgery, Jackson Wang cancels fan-sign after getting food poisoning
    • Lil Nas X reportedly arrested for assaulting police officer
    • 13 unreleased songs by The Beatles to be in new compilation
    • Morgan Wallen reportedly not participating in 2026 Grammys

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • McDonald's teases BTS TinyTan Happy Meal, here's what we know
    • Indie darling The Projector announces immediate closure
    • 'Skibidi', 'delulu' and other social media words now found in Cambridge dictionary
    • From froyo to acai: Australian dessert chain Yo-Chi launches first international outlet in Singapore
    • The 'bridge to heaven': Things to do in Amanohashidate, Japan
    • I banned screens at the table for 2 weeks, here's what actually changed
    • Feeling awful after a great trip? How to solve it without booking another escape (for now)
    • Machu Picchu VR experience coming to Singapore in September, voiced by Terry Crews
    • Free breakfast for P6 pupils at Cheers, FairPrice Xpress outlets in September
    • From island-themed installations to festival villages: What to expect at Singapore Night Festival 2025

Digicult

Digicult
    • Black Myth: Wukong to get sequel featuring ghost-hunting deity Zhong Kui
    • Google Pixel Watch 4 and Pixel Buds 2a: Built to last longer with replaceable batteries
    • Singaporean Robert Sim receives one of Wikipedia's highest honours for his work on online platform
    • Tabletop, card games convention TableCon Quest 2025 triples in size as Bushiroad lands in Singapore
    • NDR2025: Govt to study new laws to protect kids from harmful, toxic content online
    • Apple Maps brings 3D landmarks and road-level realism to Singapore
    • The best AI tutor for O-level subjects: ChatGPT, Gemini or The Wise Otter?
    • Vivo X Fold5: A foldable contender with a few class-leading surprises
    • Here's everything in GPT-5 that's new and different than OpenAI's previous AI models
    • Australia regulator says YouTube, others 'turning a blind eye' to child abuse material

Money

Money
    • 5 unique ways you can use your SG60/CDC vouchers
    • Singapore indie cinema The Projector owes over $1.2m to creditors
    • Global markets face shaky week ahead as US pressure mounts on Ukraine
    • 6 best cashback credit cards in Singapore (August 2025)
    • Best bank offers in Singapore (August 2025): Limited-edition Stitch charms, 50% off flights and more
    • 9 best personal loans in Singapore with lowest interest rates (August 2025)
    • Best credit card promotions in Singapore (August 2025): Citibank, DBS, HSBC, UOB and more
    • Ninja Van cuts 12% of Singapore workforce after 2 rounds of layoffs in 2024
    • Goh Cheng Liang, Nippon Paint billionaire and richest Singaporean, dies aged 98
    • Singapore upgrades 2025 growth forecast but warns that outlook remains 'clouded by uncertainty'

Latest

Latest
  • With no Ukraine peace deal, Trump again threatens Russia sanctions
  • South Korea's Lee in Japan to shore up ties before meeting US President Trump
  • Trump threatens federal intervention in Chicago, government takeover in DC
  • Gambian man sentenced to more than 67 years after US conviction for torture
  • Meta signs over $12.8b cloud deal with Google, source says
  • Putin sees 'light at end of the tunnel' in Russia-US ties, cooperation in Arctic and Alaska
  • Online death of abused French streamer was not result of trauma, prosecutor says
  • Eswatini government faces court challenge for accepting US deportees
  • Troop costs, China in focus when South Korea's Lee meets US President Trump

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • Van driver in Malaysia arrested for dropping off school kids while vehicle was still moving
  • Malaysian teachers caught vaping on school grounds may face fines, up to 2 years' jail
  • Shoelace to tie umbilical cord: Woman in Malaysia goes into labour by roadside, passing motorists help deliver baby
  • Man remanded after wielding knife, trying to snatch baby in Penang supermarket
  • 2 Singapore drivers allegedly detained in Legoland for offering illegal ride-hailing services; cars seized
  • Vers likely to be launched in next decade: Chee Hong Tat
  • Malaysia's border control agency gives ICA cake to mark SG60
  • Tourist in Hong Kong killed after cabby, 80, crashes into pillar outside hotel
  • 2 Malaysian men nabbed at Woodlands Checkpoint for allegedly smuggling drugs worth over $150k into Singapore
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.